Dividendology on $COST (Nov 11, 2026)
Costco's business model and capital allocation are strong—about 90% membership renewal, predictable cash flows, 15-20% ROIC—and the $30 special dividend makes sense because buybacks at ~47x earnings would be unlikely to create value. But at ~46-47x PE, valuation is the main risk: at ~9.4% EPS growth and a ~52x multiple, forward returns are ~9-10%; a reversion to ~40x could mean ~6 years of subpar returns even with dividends. The speaker hasn't added COST and wants a lower PE entry.
Playing via YouTube may share device and playback data and use cookies. Privacy Notice · Google Privacy Policy
Jump to any passage
Costco stock has historically been an incredible compounder. Over the last decade, they're up over 616%. And when we look at their performance relative to the S&P 500, they've outperformed from a total return basis over the last year.
Over the last 3 years, over the last 5 years, they've basically doubled the performance. And over the past decade, they have demolished the S&P 500.
And today, we have news that shareholders are rejoicing to. Costco just announced that they're going to be paying out a $30 special dividend. So, for every share of Costco that you hold, they're going to be paying you $30 on December 4th.
Now, if we take a look at the dividend history for Costco, here's what you'll notice. The data will load into my spreadsheet automatically thanks to ticker data, and you can see the starting yield for Costco as of right now is just 0.53%.
But what's really perhaps even more interesting is when you look at the dividend history for this stock, you'll notice there's a few years where they pay out substantially more in dividends than previous years, but generally speaking, we're trending upwards.
Now, why is this the case? Well, it's relatively simple. What we've seen from Costco from a capital allocation perspective is every few years they tend to pay out a very large special dividend.
And so for reference, in 2023, the total amount they paid out in dividends, including the huge special dividend they paid out was around $18.96.
So the special dividend that they're paying out this year on December 4th, even not including their typical, their ordinary dividends at $30, we can see is by far more than they've ever paid out in any single year.
So there's a lot we need to break down in this video. Why is Costco doing this? Is this a good capital allocation move? and what does the valuation for Costco actually look like moving forward and of course why Costco is such a beautiful business model.
Now like I pointed out earlier, Costco over the last decade has just seen ridiculous outperformance relative to the S&P 500 despite the fact the past decade is really one of the best decades for the S&P 500 in history with total returns of 244%.
Now, one of the obvious critiques a lot of people make from Costco stock is the fact it trades at a very expensive valuation. In fact, if we look at the PE multiple right now, they're trading at about 46 close to 47 times earnings.
I mean, this is a very expensive stock, especially considering it's not a high growth tech stock.
So, one of the things we need to ask oursel first off is what allowed Costco to achieve these type of returns over the last decade? And really to answer that question, we have to look at Costco through what you should know as the sources of returns.
What do I mean by this? Well, ultimately what we know about Costco or any stock in general is returns come from three different sources. They only come from three different places.
It's one earnings growth, two, dividends, and three, change in the valuation multiple.
If a stock is trading at the same valuation multiple and earnings growth continues to go higher, the stock price goes higher. If a stock is paying out dividends, that contributes to total returns.
And even if they don't pay dividends and earnings per share stays completely flat. If the valuation multiple expands, again, that's going to contribute to total returns for a stock.
And what we can see from Costco is when we look 10 years ago, they were able to benefit from all three sources of returns. We can see earnings growth contributed about 330 points, dividends about 103 points, and then valuation multiple expansion about 146 points.
But here's what we really have to understand. Yes, earnings growth was substantial, and that obviously pushes the share price higher. But the stock over the last decade also went from a PE multiple of roughly 25.5 times earnings according to ticker, again, now all the way up to 46.75.
And so anytime we have a stock trading at this much of a premium, this can only be justified in two different ways. One, if we analyze if the stock is growing earnings at a rate fast enough to justify a high valuation multiple.
And two, if the stock has incredibly predictable cash flows.
And so we need to look at both of those things very closely. So, if we go ahead and jump over to our stock screener, come up here and plug in Costco, what you will see is when we look at earnings per share growth is they have seen pretty strong growth over the past decade, going from $541 in 2015 to at the end of 2025 about $18.24.
To put that into just a little more perspective, look at our sensitivity analysis. What you'll see is the compounded annual EPS growth rate since 2018 is about 14.27%. So, really strong earnings growth for Costco during this time period, which to some degree absolutely does deserve a premium valuation relative to the S&P 500.
But what you'll also notice, and this is perhaps just as important, is how stable, predictable these cash flows have been. Whether we're looking at revenue per share or earnings per share, the cash flows have been incredibly predictable.
And this is where we really have to understand the overall business model for Costco. If we jump over to their Q4 earnings presentation, take a close look at this. Yes, there's plenty of things we could break down.
The way that earnings and revenues are growing, what ticket prices are doing. We scroll down and we can see different segments, but this is what continues to blow me away. This number right here, the worldwide membership renewal rate.
Now, we have to remember Costco has a membership program. You basically have to be a Costco member to get access to their facilities. And we can see that the renewal rate to be a Costco member is essentially 90% worldwide.
I think a lot of investors don't understand just how mind-blowing this is. I mean, most businesses, whether a software or any subscription business, would absolutely kill to have a 90% membership renewal rate. It's absolutely phenomenal.
And it's one of the reasons that Costco has such predictable cash flows, whether you're looking at revenue per share or earnings per share. And again, that's one of the elements that causes a stock to trade at a premium, especially when we're in the age of AI.
Everybody is worried about AI disrupting every single business. But Costco is one of those stocks that trades at a premium right now, simply due to the fact that investors feel like AI, at least over the next 5 to 10 years, doesn't really have a chance to disrupt it in any way.
This is why the stock trades at a premium. Now, we'll come back and talk about that valuation again in just a moment and why it is a potential concern. But let's talk about the special dividend again for a moment.
Why does this actually make sense for the stock or does it make sense at all? I mean, a $30 special dividend again is significantly higher than they paid out in dividends in 2025 at just around $5 a share.
And so, let's dive into this. If we look at this for reference, the $30 special dividend means they're going to pay out about 142% of their free cash flow generated in the latest fiscal year. That's right, 142% of their free cash flow.
So, the first thing we have to ask is, is that a bad decision? Well, first off, what we'll notice is whenever they paid out a special dividend in the past, it very often, very frequently, has been over 100% of the free cash flow that they've used.
We can see this in multiple instances when in 2021 they used 107% of their free cash flow and in 2024 they used around 136. This really isn't uncommon. They're more than willing to pay out a special dividend that's more than their free cash flow.
Why is that the case? Well, it's because they stockpile a lot of cash in short-term investments. Costco ended that year with 21.3 billion in cash.
Now, the special dividend alone is almost 4 billion more than it generated in free cash flow for the full year. And just for reference, we can see in 2025, they generated around 7.8 billion in free cash flow.
Once the special dividend is paid, they will have distributed about $35.71 per share over the last 12 months. And what's interesting is, yes, that dividend yield right now is sitting at just about 0.53%.
But once the special dividend is paid, their trailing yield will be roughly 3.35%.
Now, there's a lot of information right here, and a lot of it's actually very important. And again, we have to approach this more than anything from the standpoint of capital allocation.
Why did Costco choose to do this? Because again, we have to remember there's five different ways that they can allocate their capital. One, they can reinvest back into the business.
Two, they could pay down debt. Three, do mergers and acquisitions. Four, buy back shares. Or five, pay out dividends.
Now, the first question we need to assess is why are they not just simply reinvesting this capital back into the business? And the key metric we really need to pay close attention to for Costco is return on invested capital.
This essentially is telling us how profitable are the projects the company is reinvesting their capital back into.
And so we can see over the last few years it's been pretty strong for a retailer. Costco has typically been in that 15 to 20% return on invested capital range. That's actually quite strong and typically for reference as a baseline, we want this to be at least 10%.
Anytime their return on invested capital is above their weighted average cost of capital, then they're generating shareholder value.
But one of the mistakes a lot of people make is when they realize return on invested capital is a backwards looking metric. If Costco all of a sudden tried to allocate all their short-term investments and cash into projects, even if they can't find advantageous projects to reinvest it into, then their return on invested capital would undoubtedly drop dramatically.
This is true with a lot of stocks. They have high return on invested capital because it's easier to allocate capital if you're not reinvesting as much.
So, what management is telling us is they're happy with the investment opportunities they have right now and being able to generate that 15 to 20% return on invested capital with that investment.
But that's not the only thing we have to assess. With that being said, why are they not paying down debt? Why are they not buying back shares? Why did they choose to pay a dividend?
Well, I think in terms of debt, the short answer is they have a strong balance sheet. They're already sitting on a large cash position, which is the reason they're able to pay this dividend in the first place since they're using 142% of their free cash flow based on the latest fiscal year.
So now, this basically leaves us with two options. Why are they electing to pay out a dividend instead of buying back shares? A lot of the times we hear that argument that buybacks are more tax advantageous.
And to some degree that can be true in a lot of cases, but there's a lot of times where buybacks are actually not in the best interest of shareholders. When done properly, they're absolutely phenomenal.
And there's plenty of case studies of that. And it even benefits dividend investors as well.
But here's a very simple way to analyze if share buybacks are advantageous. If a stock is trading above its intrinsic value, buying back shares is actually not a good idea. In fact, it can even destroy shareholder value.
And that's when paying out a steady, predictable dividend becomes far more attractive.
And so, when we see a stock like Costco trading at basically 47 times earnings, you really have to ask if buying back shares at these levels would be beneficial. It's possible, but I think the answer is very unlikely not the case.
And so naturally, the only capital allocation decision that makes sense for Costco is the special dividend. And keep in mind, the special dividend gives them a lot more flexibility.
It's not the ordinary dividend that they're always committed to paying. They can be a little more discretionary with this. So if opportunities do arise, they can allocate capital as they see fit.
And so when we talk about whether or not this is a good decision, you can see what a lot of analysts out in the banking world are stating. Jeffre viewed the special dividend announcement positively and sees the magnitude of the payout as further highlighting the strength, consistency, and cash generative nature of Costco's business model. That's basically what we just said.
If we look at Evercore, we can see they noted the dividend payout is 50% above the expected level. And the firm views the broader opportunity for Costco shareholders as the valued share of the consumer wallet, not broad grocery reflation with Asian openings offering a membership growth accelerator in fiscal year 28.
Other analysts believe that this dividend was fired off because the retailer feels emboldened by adding additional liquidity from tariff funds and excess fuel profitability. Banks that were more critical pointed out something that we pointed out as well.
Given that the expected 13.3 billion in total dividends exceeds the annual free cash flow threshold, the company will be dipping into the cash balance they've accumulated over the past 3 years.
And again, this is absolutely true, but it's why we also pointed out they have a very strong cash position, maybe sitting on more cash than they want to, which again would make sense why they're actually paying out the special dividend.
Now, with all that being said, we understand the business model a little more, why this capital allocation decision makes sense, and what this actually means for the company in terms of dividend coverage.
But is Costco interesting at current prices, trading at a PE multiple all the way up 47 times earnings?
Now, at peak in 2025, we can see at one point before the tariff scare, they were trading at nearly 58 times earnings, and the stock PE multiple pulled back quite a bit since then.
But what do forward-looking returns actually look like for this stock? And this is where I start to have some concerns about the valuation multiple they're trading at. Because if we look at the projected EPS kagger, according to analysts through the year 2031, it's about 9.4%.
Just slightly lower than what we've seen over the last few years.
So if they hit that 9.4% 4% EPS growth rate. If they continue to trade at the same valuation multiple that they have over the last year, which is a trailing 12-month PE multiple of about 52, you can see forward-looking returns are pretty much in line with earnings growth about 9 close to 10%.
But here's what's scary. If Costco sees a reversion in the PE multiple back to maybe even 2022 or 2023 levels, this is where the math starts to really hurt shareholders. We can see the trolling 12-month PE multiple on average in 2022 and 2023 was around 40 times earnings.
Look at what happens all of a sudden. Now you're looking at roughly 6 years of very subpar returns even if you include the dividend.
So what does this mean for the stock? Well, the business model isn't at risk from AI. In fact, that's why people are paying a premium for it. The overall risk for Costco is valuation risk.
The past decade has been absolutely incredible for shareholders because again they've benefited from all three of the sources of returns. But what if one of these sources of returns in particular the valuation multiple starts working against you?
It's not like back in 2016 or 2017 when they were starting at around a 25 26p multiple. Now they're trading at above 45 times earnings. So just imagine what happens if yes earnings and dividends continue to grow but the valuation multiple sees a significant decline. it really starts to eat into those earnings.
And so that's my concern for Costco and it's the reason I haven't been able to add it to my portfolio. I love the business model. I love the capital allocation priorities of the company.
But paying too high a price for a stock can offset an entire decades of what would otherwise be phenomenal returns.
And so I'm rooting for Costco shareholders. I hope they can continue to maintain this high PE multiple. But in reality, I'd actually love to see the PE multiple come down so I can get an attractive entry price.
But until that happens, I'll continue to have it on my watch list.