$RDDT

The Intrinsic Value Podcast on $RDDT (Nov 14, 2026)

AI summary · The Intrinsic Value Podcast

RDDT earns roughly 91% gross margins and over 100% returns on capital, but Google traffic is now the biggest risk, with search referrals falling and daily users potentially shrinking double digits next quarter. Fair value is lower than a year ago and outcomes are wider, yet the speaker is a happy buyer below $100, a low-20s multiple of owner's earnings against about 40% guided growth; not an existential threat to long-term shareholders.

BullishHe framed it in years
“Reddit (RDDT): Record Cash Flow, Collapsing Share Price”
The Intrinsic Value PodcastPublished Nov 14 · 146 passages

Playing via YouTube may share device and playback data and use cookies. Privacy Notice · Google Privacy Policy

Jump to any passage

146 passages
0:2261:36

And this week, Reddit warned that its daily users could shrink next quarter, and then the stock fell 30% in a day at the time of recording, even with revenue growing more than 50% year over year in the last quarter.

So is Reddit a network nobody can truly replace, or just a tenant whose landlord just opened a competing store next door?

I've used Reddit on and off since high school, but for years I never thought of it as an investment. The shares were private anyways and honestly, I could not remember ever seeing an ad on the platform.

So, I really didn't think that there was much of a business case to be made for it, but ever since then I've been just absolutely blown away by what management has accomplished.

Growth is off the charts and they're earning much more per user than they ever did in the past and it's a good time to revisit Reddit because at the time of recording here, Reddit shares have dropped 30% following their Q3 earnings report, dragging the stock down 60% for the year, which is really quite the 180 for one of our best performers from 2025.

Yeah, and actually the craziest part is that this is actually the second 20% plus drawdown in a single day in the last 3 months. So, back in July the stock fell about 21% the day after the company reported a quarter where revenue grew more than 60% and profits nearly tripled.

So, yesterday Reddit grew revenues even more than beat Wall Street on both sales and profits, expanded its margins, and the stock still got crushed. So, normally a drop like that comes with a disastrous quarter and in neither case was that true.

And drops like that don't shock me anymore as a Reddit shareholder. I mean, this stock has been an absolute roller coaster ride ever since the first day I owned it and I was really there for the first ride.

For anyone who missed my original pitch on Reddit, I do have it linked in the show notes, but I actually ended up participating in the IPO and I was quite familiar with Reddit since as you had mentioned I was a moderator of TIPs subreddit and for doing so I got an allocation at the $34 IPO price, which for context, Reddit wanted to give its most active users the chance to buy in at the same price institutional investors could and and have a stake of ownership in the platform that they love.

So, for being a moderator I had the chance to participate and basically on IPO day the stock popped about 50% and I tried to lock that gain in as quickly as possible because I knew I wasn't comfortable owning what was at the time an unprofitable social media business after seeing especially how much value had been destroyed at Twitter previously.

And yet I knew Reddit was a hot IPO. So I sort of rolled the dice. It was a bit of a fun gamble betting that the shares would pop on IPO day, which they did. But I definitely knew I didn't want to hold it for any longer than that.

I wasn't a long-term holder. And honestly, I still think that was probably the right thought process even though the stock did actually go much higher after I sold. And the way I think of it is if you can't get comfortable owning something, it is fine to sell.

So in my original pitch, I valued Reddit at between $120 and $135 a share. And at the time, it was actually trading above that price. But I said that I would love to own it if it ever came back down to that price range.

And it did. And we ended up building a position in the portfolio at an average cost of about $105. So my Reddit investing experience includes one trade I made money on personally, but probably shouldn't have been in as a value investor.

And then one investment that more than doubled at its peak and then came full circle as of the time of recording.

Yeah, so when a position doubles, it's pretty easy to get lazy about re-underwriting it. When it gives it all back in a few months though, you know, it's very easy to panic. So I think neither is probably the optimal way to make decisions.

So after this current drop, it's close to being about 3 and 1/2% of the portfolio. So if we still believe in the business, this could be a chance to add.

And your original episode gave us a really nice time capsule. So when you recorded it, Reddit had its first profitable year and daily users were around 100 million. But the big question was whether a platform built around limiting user data could sell targeted ads like Meta or whether its monetization would stall out like Snapchat.

Now if we fast forward to today, Reddit just did about $900 million of revenue in a single quarter, up more than 50% with about a third of every dollar sales turning into profit.

So over the last 12 months, it's generated well over a billion dollars of free cash flow. So I think Reddit is really a business that is clearly capable of printing cash and a lot of it.

But the tougher question is just what comes next. This was the first quarter in nearly two years that growth came in under 60% and management guided to roughly about 40% growth in the next quarter, which is a little bit below what Wall Street wanted it to be.

And the market just, you know, they hate decelerating growth even when it's still very very high.

Exactly. And when a business can grow faster than almost anything in the market and still get absolutely hammered the moment investors decide the next quarter won't be as magical, particularly when it's priced at a huge multiple to the market.

It's like the kid who consistently gets straight A's then gets grounded for, you know, one A minus. So I don't think I'll be the dad grounding my son for that, but I have many more years until that potentially becomes a reality.

But, you know, just to judge the slowdown here, we need to kind of look a little more under the hood. So Reddit isn't just one engine, it's a handful of engines. So some are running quite hot, some are probably sputtering, and a couple of have probably not even been switched on yet.

So if we understand each of them, we'll have a much better sense of whether the market was right to panic. And I will admit before this episode, I hadn't really given Reddit's business model that much thought.

I just wanted to know how to grow lettuce. I didn't appreciate how good the business really was until I dug in a little bit more.

Most Reddit users never think about the fact that they're inside a business at all. And when it does come up, it's actually a very taboo and sensitive topic on Reddit. Reddit often feels like just a place where you go to argue over which vacuum has the best suction power.

But those can actually make for very fertile ad space. And over the last few years, Reddit has drastically improved at its ability to sell and and monetize those spaces.

Right. And that vacuum argument is a pretty good illustration of how this whole thing really works. So Reddit has about 130 million daily users and over 27 billion yes, 27 billion posts and comments.

They're all neatly organized into something called subreddits, which are these discussion forums that are built around a single topic. There are ones for growing lettuce. There's one for people with high energy dogs and then tens of thousands more for topics that you wouldn't even think that a single person on earth would care about.

Users make a post, other users add comments, and then people vote. The best answers float to the top and the worst answers sink to the bottom. Now, Reddit doesn't create the content.

It's all user based, kind of like YouTube. To make things even better for Reddit, they have an army of volunteer moderators who run each community and do things like set the rules and clean up any spam.

And they do this all for zero dollars. So Reddit's job is basically just to be the landlord. They keep the building standing, keep the lights on, and rent out all of the wall space.

But the wall space there is where the real money is. So advertising is about 95% of the revenue. The rest of the revenue is definitely a hot topic. So Reddit labels it as other revenue.

And this ends up being mostly from data licensing to AI companies such as Google or OpenAI. Also lumped in is its revenue from Reddit premium subscriptions.

Yeah, the premium subscriptions is pretty negligible. It's a rounding error. But there has definitely been a lot of talk about Reddit being something of an AI company within that other revenue line.

That's only 5% of sales, as you mentioned. And it grew slower than ads last quarter. So I definitely would push back on the market narrative of Reddit being an AI company or an AI beneficiary, however you want to think about it.

I've always preferred to focus on the core business than the licensing money for data because it just never seemed that durable to me and as a long time user of the product I was always more interested in how they could monetize other long-term users like myself and the more interesting AI story is actually on the advertising side.

AI is what's making Reddit's ads better targeted and easier to buy and that's where the real money has proven to be but Reddit has a different ads business compared to something like Facebook or or Instagram.

Meta knows a lot of things about its users. It knows your age, where you live, who your friends are and that you've been looking at Christmas trees over the past few weeks and on Reddit most users are synonymous and many users never log in at all so instead of targeting individual users it targets the conversations that people are having on subreddits and if you're on a home espresso subreddit you might see an ad for a coffee grinder and it's called contextual advertising when this happens and the magic really is in the timing of these ads.

So where Instagram might show you a running shoe ad while you were just watching videos of puppies or whatever whatever else you do on Instagram Reddit will show you a shoe ad while you're reading a subreddit on the best shoes for people with flat feet and so a way to think of it is Meta is like a salesperson who's just following you around the mall at all times making suggestions wherever you go whereas Reddit is like this salesperson that's standing in the shoe aisle when you're already looking for shoes and prepared to help drive that conversion and that is sort of the simplest way I would compare the differences.

No, I think that's a great comparison. So the pitch to advertisers I think is that the shoe aisle salesperson using your metaphor is probably going to close more deals and the numbers I think actually back it up.

So over the summer Reddit said that its number of active advertisers grew about 70% and conversions more than doubled and this quarter ad revenue grew by more than 50% driven by both higher prices and more ads shown but I I the really interesting part is when you think about who the advertisers are on the platform.

It's changed for the better as Reddit has scaled up. So in the beginning, Reddit's ad business was mostly just, you know, national brands who are buying through these gigantic ad agencies.

But today, they still have that as part of their business, but they're also growing the small and mid-sized business segment as well. So revenue from that group actually doubled year over year and a lot of that is coming from Reddit Max, which is its AI campaign tool which just became available for every advertiser this past quarter.

Reddit Max is a big deal for smaller advertisers. Most small businesses don't have an ad team and with Reddit Max, a business just tells Reddit what it wants, whether that's a sale or an app download and Reddit's algorithm then figures out who should see the ad and how to get it to them.

And it helps turn Reddit from a business only large ad agencies would be able to utilize into something that a local owner of something as mundane as a gardening center could be able to set up and use in one afternoon.

I know you like your uh your Lettuce Cow. And the growth isn't necessarily coming from one hot category, right? Over the summer, management said 11 of its 15 industry verticals grew more than 50% and that breadth held up again this quarter led by things like travel and retail.

But they're doing a really good job diversifying and leaning into things like shopping. They have something called dynamic product ads which can help turn a store's product catalog into ads.

And so they have 500 stores that are already connected. And so this is where the ad story gets complicated and also where we can have a conversation about what is really starting to make the market nervous, right?

Not every visitor is worth the same to an advertiser. And that is a big reason that its share price is is currently in the dumps.

Yeah, and I think this took me a little while to really get my head around it. So those 130 million daily users are really in kind of two completely different groups. So let me break this down.

So the first group is probably the group that Sean belongs to. You know, they're people who are logging in, they have accounts, they use the app, they subscribe to different communities and come back on a pretty regular basis.

The second group is probably where I'd belong. These are people who arrive usually from a Google search. They might just read one thread and then they're just going to leave. But a logged-in user is worth roughly three times as much as a logged-out one simply because they just stick around longer and can therefore see more ads.

In fact, management says logged-in and app users drive more than 80% of Reddit's revenue. Since I live by the Rocky Mountains, let me kind of give you a ski hill example here. So let say you've got these kind of season pass ticket holders who tend to go to the mountain for as many weekends as possible during the ski season.

They're not only using the mountain, but they're also paying $10 for overpriced hot chocolate every time they go, plus whatever food they end up getting from the lodge. Then you've got the day trippers.

These are the ones that just drive up on a whim. They might ski a few runs and then just head home. The hills definitely need both of them, but it's obvious which cohort is going to generate the most revenue for the ski hill.

Now the last time I went snowboarding, I was definitely a day tripper, but I still ended up buying the overpriced hot chocolate. >> Just uh to stretch your ski hill metaphor a little bit, it also matters where the season pass holder lives, which wouldn't actually matter so much in real life, but you know, last quarter, for example, Reddit earned almost $14 from each daily American user versus less than $2.50 from each international user.

Just uh to stretch your ski hill metaphor a little bit, it also matters where the season pass holder lives, which wouldn't actually matter so much in real life, but you know, last quarter, for example, Reddit earned almost $14 from each daily American user versus less than $2.50 from each international user.

So one American user is worth more than five times international ones. And this doesn't mean that Americans are are better redditors. It just means that US advertisers pay a lot more per ad than advertisers in other countries.

And that's why about 80% of Reddit's revenue comes from the US, even though international users make up about the majority of its user base actually. So Reddit's most valuable users are logged-in Americans.

And that group grew just 1% again this quarter. And so then the real gut punch came when Steve Huffman, the CEO, said traffic from Google search had fallen meaningfully during the quarter and that it's actually kept falling through October by more than a million visits a week.

If that keeps up, Reddit's daily user count could shrink by a double digit percentage number next quarter, which is very very scary. And then they still don't have a renewed data deal with Google either.

So there's definitely a tension between Reddit and Google at the moment. And the other thing that raised eyebrows happened a bit earlier this year, and that was when management said it was going to phase out reporting of the split of logged in versus logged out users right as growth in logged in users was stalling.

When a company suddenly stops reporting a metric, it's not usually because that metric is improving, right? I mean, in some cases, yes, the metric being obfuscated is definitely worsening, but also there's an argument to be made that it maybe it's not as representative of the business's health anymore.

And that's why management wants to phase it out. I would say that's a generous interpretation for managers. And I think in most cases it's probably a mix of both. Something is worsening and it's not great for the company, but perhaps the metric isn't as critical and important as the market thinks it is. So for me, it's it's a yellow flag.

Yeah. And you know, I think usually it's probably a red flag or maybe at least a yellow flag. So I know when I look at businesses, I like to review the KPIs that they've used historically, whether that's, you know, maybe a couple years ago, and then I like to look at today and see if they're still using them.

So if I think they had a really good KPI 5 years ago and now they're missing, I personally have to ask why. And usually it signals that something has fundamentally changed in the business. So

So here's the base case as I see it. Reddit's most valuable users are barely growing, and the cheap growth that it used to get from Google is now going basically in reverse.

And Huffman basically said that Google has gone from a traffic driver to something else entirely. Meanwhile, the data deal with Google is still being renegotiated. So, the argument is that Reddit can't squeeze enough out of its seasoned pass holders alone.

Raising ad prices definitely can carry a lot, but you know, it's not going to keep growth going at 50 or 60% forever.

Reddit allows those users to actually all meet in the same place. And as you mentioned, Kyle, the people running these rooms are volunteers, right? It's not often that you find a company powered by volunteers, but that's very much the case with Reddit.

And Reddit has 20 years of real people's experiences sitting in its archives. And I don't really think you can recreate that overnight. And Reddit has positioned that data in a way that is now easily searchable.

This is why Google tends to rank Reddit so highly, and it's also why Google and OpenAI have both paid a pretty handsome sum to Reddit to license the data, at least in the past.

And the tricky thing is that at the same time, a lot of Reddit's recent user growth came from Google choosing to feature Reddit Threads in its search results.

And so the big difference is that BuzzFeed's whole business was from those drive-by visitors, whereas fortunately for Reddit, logged in and app users drive more than 80% of revenue.

So losing Google traffic hurts the user count figures a lot more than it hurts the income statement, at least for the time being.

And funny enough, Reddit is about to run that bar experiment that you mentioned, Kyle, sort of in reverse. They're going logged in only, and that's sort of like putting a bouncer at the door who asks for your name on the way into the bar.

Some day trippers are going to sign up and become regulars, and others are just going to move on to the next bar.

No, that's a good one. And I think it's part of the reason why I was torn when I ran Reddit through my kind of moat checklist that I like to run all my businesses through.

But even if Google and OpenAI keep paying for the data, that doesn't really solve the problem of getting people to actually click through to Reddit.

And that 's why I actually like the logged in only move. It's a defensive move, even if it costs some users in the short run. Basically, it puts a lock on the front door if you want to think of it that way.

If Google and OpenAI or anybody else wants Reddit's conversations and content, they'll have to pay for them instead of Reddit handing that product out for free to the same company that's actually cutting the flow of traffic to their app and website.

And where you're right, Kyle, is that a licensing check doesn't replace the habit of logging in. So there's only so much you can get from licensing out your data. I mean, it's nice money to have, but the present value of it is considerably smaller than the future ad revenue that you would get from from a new lifetime user.

Right. And I think the other advantage here, you kind of just alluded to was just in loyalty, right? So Reddit's core users stick around for their communities, their relationships, their identity on the site, and let's be honest, just plain old habit.

That's why the logged in numbers matter so much. If the group that comes back out of habit stops growing, well, then the moat doesn't disappear, but it stops being a growth engine.

Now the good news is that this quarter, the logged in and app users actually did grow from the prior quarter, and new app users are sticking around much better. So the first week retention was up more than 50% versus a year ago.

And funny enough, Reddit's famously confusing interface actually cuts both ways. So long time users have already climbed the learning curve, which probably helps protect Reddit from potential copycats.

But it also serves to scare off newcomers like myself because, you know, these day pass visitors who probably never end up signing up simply because they just don't want to learn how it all works.

But during the pandemic, I spent hours trying to decode sort of the secret language that had formed around Wall Street Bets. And I was already a regular Reddit user at the time too, and I found it very difficult.

But I think the learning curve is as much a feature as it is a bug, right? Every subreddit has its own slang, its own inside jokes, and its own written and unwritten rules. And so once you're in, that is really what makes it feel like a community.

And it's very difficult for a competitor to copy that culture.

And the flip side is that it's also why so many day trippers never stick around. Reddit can feel exclusionary in some ways, and it's a big part of why Reddit isn't as big as Facebook and never will be despite them coming out around the same time.

And back around Reddit's IPO days, the top 10 advertisers made up a quarter of their revenue. And so that was a lot of concentration risk for Reddit. And Reddit's business and stock really hasn't been tested through an advertising recession either, at least not as a profitable company.

And so if we got hit with another 2008 or 2020, ad budgets would absolutely get cut. And we just don't know how hard Reddit would be hit.

But I think Reddit has done a pretty good job on the diversification front with these small businesses that it's leaning into. My guess is that customer concentration risk has correspondingly fallen and probably pretty meaningfully.

And I say that because active advertisers grew about 70% over the past year. And small and mid-sized businesses were the fastest growing group in there.

And those tools like Reddit Max that we mentioned make it just so easy for really a long tail of smaller advertisers to show up and participate in. And so Reddit hasn't given us that exact number, so I can't prove it.

But I definitely think the mix is probably a lot healthier than it was at the time of the IPO.

Yeah, I give them a lot of credit for diversifying their customer base, which is something I definitely definitely like to see. So just to kind of give a summary here, here's where I land on the mode.

So on the user side, I think it's very formidable. Pretty much nobody else does this topic-based, pseudonymous, searchable discussion at any scale that comes close to Reddit.

If you're in something like a Facebook group, you know, it's tied to your real name, which can change what people are willing to discuss. You aren't going to have people posting, you know, is this all weird?

When their family, friends, or colleagues can read it.

Discord, it's decent, but the communities are completely private and you can't really search them unless you are part of that specific community. X or Twitter or whatever you want to call it these days tends to just break down into shouting matches and TikTok is more purely for entertainment.

So I do think Reddit is a very good product and chances are high I'll continue appending Reddit to the back of my more specific search queries. Now on the advertiser side, Reddit has to keep earning its budget every single quarter and advertisers will notice if American users do stop growing.

I'm also not crazy about Google controlling so much of Reddit's fate. And after this quarter, that's not a risk that's a few years out anymore. It's happening right now. Google's AI answers are good enough that a lot of people just never need to click into the underlying Reddit thread.

The one thing I would add is scale. Reddit's library grows every single day without Reddit paying for any of it as we've talked about. And every new conversation makes the archive more valuable to users, advertisers, and AI companies alike.

And a newcomer would need years and an army of volunteers just to get started with the same economics that Reddit has.

And so I I'd call it a strong moat on the user side. A pretty decent one with advertisers and then there's some vulnerability for sure at the top of the funnel, which is why there's been so much panic around the stock recently.

But I don't think that's an existential threat to long-term shareholders who believe in the earnings power of the Reddit platform.

And I'm sure we'll continue to see a push and pull dynamic between both sides. But Reddit is responding very firmly, and I kind of like that. And And yeah, we'll see if that shakes up things in Google's AI overviews.

But if you take a quantitative approach to Reddit's numbers, it's clear they have something of a moat. I mean, their numbers are just phenomenal. And I know you're the ROIC guy, Kyle, all about the returns on capital.

So I don't want to steal your thunder. I'll let you do the honors of breaking that down more. But I'll share a bit more on the background here.

And just to think about it for a second, Reddit doesn't own data centers, right? It rents the compute power. Doesn't pay for content because its users create it for them for free.

And it doesn't have to pay people to manage the content because they have volunteer moderators.

So that's almost a better business model than Netflix and YouTube and a whole lot of other tech companies combined. And as a result, you get gross margins that are around 91% and Reddit brings in over a million dollars of revenue per employee. So it's actually a very lean operation.

Yes, it's an incredibly lean operation there, Sean. And I'm happy to do the honors here regarding returns on invested capital. So I generally look for businesses that worst case have maybe a 15% return on invested capital number and can hopefully maintain or preferably expand that number into the near future.

The problem, or maybe I should say the beauty of Reddit is that it barely has any invested capital. So capital expenditure last quarter was just 1.2 million dollars, which is cheaper than what some people in my city pay for a two-bedroom condo.

But yeah, if you take the equity on Reddit's balance sheet and strip out roughly 3 billion of cash, well, you're left with only about 500 million dollars of invested capital, and most of that is just money that advertisers actually owe them.

And that 500 million dollar produced well over 800 million of after-tax operating profit last year. So this business earns back more of its entire invested capital every single year.

But there's a caveat. Reddit barely pays taxes right now because years of losses left a pretty vast sum of deductions against today's profits. So yes, that tax shield will eventually run out.

So today's profits are definitely a little bit flattered, you might say.

But even with a pretty normal tax bill, Reddit's return on capital would still be well over 100%. The catch with the sky-high returns on capital is usually that there's nowhere to put the extra cash.

Reddit is sitting on roughly 3 billion dollars, and that's a good problem to have. But it also means the business can't reinvest at all. Otherwise they would have, right? If they could reinvest everything at over 100% return on capital, then they absolutely would do that and would not have so much cash in the first place.

And so far Reddit has done a pretty sensible thing, and that is sit there with its excess cash and redistribute it to shareholders. In February of 2026, they announced their first ever buyback for up to a billion dollars, and they've used about a third of that up so far, and so they're making progress.

And there's another 100 million dollars on that front that went toward buybacks last quarter.

And really the real question is whether those buybacks actually shrink the share count or just mop up the stock-based comp that's being handed out to employees, because I know that'll be something that probably bothers you, Kyle.

Yes, you just reminded me of probably one of my biggest gripes with Reddit's capital allocation story here. So neither of us, I think, really like to see shares in the companies that we own get diluted.

But you know, it's just a reality that you pretty much have to live with, and it's important to try and make sense of it all.

So stock comp was about 15% of revenue last quarter, which is definitely not a low number, and that grew more than 40% from a year ago.

So, even though Reddit is a cash flow machine generating 1.2 billion of free cash flow over the last 12 months, I have to mentally subtract the stock comp because I think paying employees in shares instead of dollars is still a real cost.

But even after that adjustment, I'm still getting something close to about 800 million of owners earnings. Still an exceptional number and a number that I think is pretty important to value the business on.

But the good news is that the buybacks now are roughly offsetting the dilution. And since the buyback program was announced, the fully diluted share count has actually been pretty much flat.

But still, you know, the dilution will be a constant thorn in the investor's side. It's kind of like a bathtub with the tap on and the drain open. You know, right now they're balanced, so the water level isn't rising, but, you know, that is subject to change.

That's a pretty good uh that's a pretty good metaphor for how to think about the stock based comp and buybacks we see in a lot of companies in the market. I might have to take that one.

But yeah, on the buyback price, they paid around $150 a share last quarter, which looks expensive after the recent sell off with the stock around $100 at the time we're recording today. Definitely seems pricey.

But if Reddit is worth anywhere close to what we think it can be worth, then it definitely isn't burning money either. And it's just not the bargain bin buyback that you would expect to see from company like NVR, which is a home builder that was famous for using buybacks very strategically as part of its capital allocation to drive shareholder returns.

And then AutoZone is another company that is pretty famous as an example of that as well. And so what I actually like more than the buybacks is where the R&D money went. R&D spending has grown fast, something like 40% a year, but revenue has grown even faster, which tells me that money is is earning its keep.

And a lot of it has gone into things like machine translation, which automatically translates Reddit into other languages. And since international users have grown alongside international revenue, I think it's a pretty smart smart decision, right?

Because you're unlocking brand new customers who weren't able to reach the content before and and making more of Reddit accessible to anyone.

Exactly. I I really think that the machine translation is really just a clever cheat code because the content that it's already out there, you know, it already exists. Reddit just basically has to make it readable and they're running a similar play with Reddit answers.

So this is their AI search tool which allows users to converse with the discussions. It went from about a million weekly users at the start of 2025 to about 15 million by the end of that exact same year.

And they haven't even monetized it yet, meaning it could be another growth engine for them at some point into the future.

So I'd say that Reddit is doing a really really good job on capital allocation and the R&D outlays, but it just doesn't score quite as high on buybacks or the stock comp though.

And so besides stock-based comp to pay employees, there really aren't many substantial bills that the business has to worry about, namely because Reddit doesn't have any debt effectively.

They have roughly $3 billion in cash on the balance sheet and I expect they will continue to deploy that into buybacks, but they'll replenish it with cash generated from operations.

This is a company that does not have any problem generating cash and they also had unused credit lines which they shrank to $500 million and pushed the maturity date out to 2030.

So that's sort of the corporate equivalent of canceling a credit card you basically never use or getting an extension on it.

And on this revisit of the stock that we've been doing, I definitely have spent more time reading about Reddit's debt covenants than Reddit has ever probably spent actually using debt.

Yeah, I think, you know, there's just like you said, not much to worry about here. No interest expense, a ton of profits, and no real need to go out and raise money or issue shares just given how much cash just keeps piling into the business.

So the closest thing that they do have the debt is this $220 million a year in cloud computing commitments which they very very easily cover from their cash flow. So yeah, I think you pretty much nailed it. Not much to go into here.

There's maybe one thought I had that isn't related to debt, but it's probably still worth discussing. And we like to think about whether businesses are a win-win for society and whatever ecosystem that they they touch.

And you get some businesses that are a win for the business, but perhaps a loss for suppliers or customers. And then you get win-win situations like Costco.

And when it comes to Reddit, there's not as clear of an answer. Users get free answers. Advertisers get people who are looking for products they sell. But moderators and posters who create a lot of the value on the platform, they don't capture any value in return, especially compared with a platform like YouTube where creators get paid a split of the ad revenue that they generate.

And they do it really for the community, not the money.

And And that works right up until it doesn't, I suppose. And so as an illustration of how that can backfire, in 2023 Reddit started charging third-party apps for access to its data.

And many moderators relied on these third-party apps for context. And so as a protest, thousands of subreddits went dark, and they responded by telling moderators that they had to come back online or they'd be replaced with moderators who would go online and keep the subreddits active.

And it worked, but it still showed everyone that the community does have a lot of power, maybe even more power than Reddit would like to see. And I remember the whole time it just being very confusing and then also kind of hilarious because some of the biggest subreddits would protest with these memes where they would only post John Oliver, the comedian, for for several days.

And that's just very quintessential internet humor and a great epitome of a Reddit protest.

But underneath the jokes, I do think there was a real reminder that the moderators don't actually own the communities that some of them have spent years of their life building.

And Reddit can squander away the goodwill that it has with those moderators by making decisions that are better for the business and not so good for the moderators. Their incentives are not always perfectly aligned.

Yeah, and I think this all really goes back to the point earlier about who really owns the content, right? Reddit still does and they have leverage over their mods, but it's clear that the mods can definitely stir up some trouble at least for a time if they feel they've been slighted in any way.

So since Reddit relies on a lot of free labor, it's vital for them to ensure that their creators and their mods are happy because Reddit's business model doesn't work nearly as well if they have to start shelling out dollars for content creators.

So it doesn't touch the balance sheet today, but it's a real risk because, you know, free labor is a big part of why Reddit's margins are just so good. You know, 91% gross margins, I mean it's it's insane.

But the balance sheet is really only as clean as the person deciding what to do with it. And that man is Steve Huffman. So Sean, I know that you've got a real soft spot for Huffman's backstory.

I think he's an interesting character. Yeah, Steve Huffman, Reddit's founder and CEO, does have a pretty interesting background. I mean basically in 2005, Steve and his college roommate Alexis Ohanian pitched Y Combinator on an app by ordering food by text message.

And so Y Combinator, the famous group for developing young startups, ended up rejecting the idea but really liked Steve and Alexis and told them to go try building something else and and come back.

And so they took that advice to heart and came back with what they referred to as the front page of the internet. And about a year later though, they sold their stake in Reddit to Condé Nast for a ballpark price of maybe 10 or 20 million dollars.

And so Huffman actually ended up then leaving and co-founded a travel site and then he watched from afar as Reddit grew beyond what he ever expected.

And then by 2015, the company was really in something of a mess. It was having some real trouble. And so Huffman was brought back in as as CEO and that's where he's remained ever since.

And gosh, I just I can't imagine. I mean I felt bad enough selling my IPO shares after a 50% pop and then watching the stock go up something like sixfold from there. Huffman sold the whole company for maybe 10 or 20 million dollars, as I said, and watched it become worth tens of billions of dollars.

And so, the difference is I guess he got the chance to come back and fix it. And honestly, in a way, so did I, but on a much smaller scale.

Well, Sean, I think maybe you and Huffman need to start a Reddit early seller support group. I'm sure there's a subreddit that exists out there somewhere. But, you know, his second term as CEO has been quite impressive.

So, since 2020, Huffman has taken Reddit from about 230 million in revenue to more than 3 billion and operating margins from deeply, deeply negative all the way up to nearly 30%.

Yeah, revenue up more than 12-fold and margins going from very negative to nearly 30%. And I mean, that is as far as I'm concerned, he's earned his pay. And at a little over 3 million dollars last year, his pay looks pretty modest, but also it's a little misleading because he did have this giant equity grant that he received in 2023 that was valued at 192 million dollars at the time.

So, remember when we said that stock-based comp is a real problem at Reddit? And so, even though his annual comp looks puny, the compensation itself has been very lumpy.

Yeah, so he made quite the windfall back in 2023. His original package paid out at stock price targets up to about 90 dollars, but Reddit ended up blowing through those after the IPO.

So, the board ended up putting a new plan into place.

Now, I think the new plan is okay. It's tied to three things, daily users, revenue, and adjusted EBITDA, which is basically a cash profit measure. And daily users is the one number that might shrink next quarter.

So, Huffman has every reason to get it moving again.

So, the board basically reset the scoreboard after he blew past the initial benchmarks. And I think I can live with that because the business genuinely outperformed. And what I find harder to accept though was the governance structure.

Advance, which is Condé Nast's parent company, holds about 62% of the voting power, and then they have a voting agreement where Huffman's block controls roughly three-quarters of all the votes.

So, public shareholders like us really have no say in what happens in the company.

And one fascinating detail about Hoffman and maybe an insight into his psyche is that he's spent 1.1 million dollars on personal security last year. So that's about a third of his reported annual compensation.

And believe it or not, I don't think it's entirely for his own ego. I mean, when you have a large group of Redditors out there, things can probably get a little dicey. He is a loved and hated figure in some ways to a lot of those people.

Yes, apparently. So in terms of control, I think, you know, just being a passenger is okay when you feel that you can trust the person who's driving the car. So in Hoffman's case, I'm not too worried about it here.

He seems to understand the business and has shareholders' interests at heart.

So he also owns about 5 million shares and options, which are worth several hundred million dollars even after this massive drop that we've had. So he definitely has some skin in the game, which I think creates some solid alignment with shareholders.

But I will say that one thing that does bug me a bit is a large amount of insider selling since the lockup ended. So the share price has done quite well. So on the one hand, I do understand that, you know,

And that's despite the company buying back its own stock. You'd think that if the stock is cheap enough for the company to buy, well, then some insiders might also join in. So I'll be telling whether anyone steps up after this drop.

So my high-level view on management is that as an operator, Hoffman is excellent. As a capital allocator, he's been solid. There's no empire building going on here and it doesn't really look like capital's being wasted on silly acquisitions or anything like that.

Now on the disclosure side, I'd give them a below average grade for planning to drop the logged in split, the one metric that I think really really shows where this business is heading.

And that's exactly the number we'll need most as Reddit goes logged in only, which brings us to risks.

And one risk we haven't touched is regulation. And I would say regulation is a bigger issue for some other social media companies. You know, Reddit does run one of the largest public forums on the internet and there is a growing regulatory burden that corresponds to that.

In the US, section 230 though, which people have been fighting over for years, largely shields platforms from liabilities associated with what users post. So somebody posts hate speech on your platform, you're not necessarily legally liable.

Europe enforces the Digital Services Act and the UK has the Online Safety Act. Australia now bans kids under 16 from social media. Each of those rules add costs and complexity for a platform that's really built around anonymous posting across hundreds of thousands of virtual communities.

And that's actually one of the reasons Hoffman gave for going logged in only, requiring people to create an account if they want to access Reddit. It's just a lot easier to keep up with the new rules and regulations like age limits when you know who's on the site.

And then there's some risk just that the stock continues to be highly sensitive to news. And we saw again in July when the Wall Street Journal reported Reddit was considering restricting Google's access to its content during renewal talks.

Stock fell about 9% that day over a deal that was reportedly only worth about $60 million or 2% of revenue.

So it's a jumpy jumpy stock which creates opportunities but can also be emotionally challenging for some people to navigate. And I don't think investors were focused on the $60 million.

They're really looking at their relationship with Google more broadly and they're much more worried about how a fight with Google would affect traffic.

And for me, the risk that worries me most is still Google. Regulation is a slow and steady cost. But you know, Google can change Reddit's traffic overnight as we've seen.

And the question I keep coming back to is whether Reddit can turn enough of those Google visitors into people who actually create accounts on Reddit before that entire traffic funnel potentially goes away.

Yeah, I think the regulation point kind of makes me think of owning, you know, a giant public park. So, you know, on most days families are going to picnic, they're going to walk their dogs, they're going to play in the park.

But you're also responsible when someone spray paints the gazebo or tramples the flowers. And every year, the city has to add a few more rules about what you have to monitor. And that really becomes a permanent tax on the business.

And I don't really see it getting any cheaper anytime soon.

So the other risk that I'd add is in compute. So Reddit's computing costs grew more than 40% last quarter. And that's still slower than revenue. But Reddit answers, machine translation and AI personalization all burn compute and Reddit does rent its service.

Now, while that's fantastic for capital efficiency, the fact is there's still a landlord who still sets the rent for them. So while gross margins are still massive, it's definitely important to pay attention to what direction they're hopefully going to move.

If I had to rank the risks, I'd probably put the Google relationship first, sensitivity to user number second, and then regulation third. Compute seems quite manageable. And with how much compute power is now coming online, there's a real case to be made whether this could actually go down over the long term.

But even with all of that taken into account, this is a business guiding for roughly 40% revenue growth next quarter while warning that its user count could actually shrink. Now, that tells you how much of the growth is coming from better monetization, not more people.

Reddit has over 500 million weekly users and nearly 190 million of them are in the US. Only about 50 million Americans show up on a daily basis. That's roughly 140 million Americans who already use Reddit to some degree, but don't come back every day.

And I don't think Reddit needs to convince millions of people to start using the platform to drive growth. It just needs to convince that chunk of 140 million people to start coming back more often.

Yeah, I wouldn't really consider myself to be even a weekly user of Reddit. Maybe I am if you count Reddit threads that I find through Google. But you know, for years, Reddit's own search was just so bad that the best way to search for Reddit was to just use Google.

It's almost like owning a library with a card catalog that's just so broken that people go to the library across the street just to find out what shelf your books are on.

They are starting to fix that fortunately. About 80 million people a week used Reddit search by the end of 2025 and that was up from 60 million a year earlier and Reddit answers, which is sort of like LLM or chatbot built into Reddit for helping you find information on Reddit is now built into the app.

So every search that starts on Reddit is one less search that depends on Google and it keeps people on Reddit in front of Reddit's advertisers instead of on Google's pages

and I'll be honest when I first looked at Reddit answers in my original pitch, I don't think I was very sold. I mean I called it a solution to a problem that didn't exist because it was just as easy to add Reddit to the end of a Google search and boy that seems really naive, but that was when Google was happily sending folks to Reddit and now that we've had this break in relations between the two and Google's AI really answers questions itself, Reddit having its own AI for scraping through its own archive of conversations and content it seems like something that's much more important to have than I gave management credit for.

Yeah, that's totally fair and you know I don't think any of that search traffic is monetized yet, which is probably what makes it even more interesting. I wouldn't put a dollar of search revenue in a base case, but I think it's kind of the upside that I'd rather get for free than to actually pay for.

Still, I think I'll probably push back on my own enthusiasm because changing how people search is one of the hardest things to do on the internet. Microsoft spent billions of dollars trying to get people to use Bing and I honestly can't remember the last time I used it.

Google is just a pure habit that I've created over time and I'm a perfect example. I didn't even know Reddit search had gotten better and even now that I do, I'll probably keep adding Reddit to my Google searches just out of habit.

So it's great that search is improving and the numbers back it up, but turning it into real revenue is still definitely a work in progress. As a Reddit shareholder I have to say that the Bing comparison stings a little bit, but Reddit does have its own advantages that Bing never had, right?

It owns its own content. Bing was always trying to beat Google at Google's own game where Reddit is just asking people to search place where the answers already live.

And the other growth lever that has worked well is in international, right? Machine translation unlocked archive of content on Reddit for people who couldn't consume any content before.

And a French speaker can now read the best English thread on fixing a bike chain in French, and then they can reply in French, and then the original poster will see it in English. So this is a pretty powerful development.

And in this quarter, international daily users grew about 25% and international revenue grew by about 1/3, which means they're growing the user count obviously, and then they're generating more revenue per user.

And it's also where Reddit will first test the logged-in only experience. So that is going to be very important to watch over the next few months. And very keen for the next Q4 earnings report to hear about that.

And then you have the data licensing arrangements. Google and OpenAI deals are reportedly worth about $130 million a year. And if other AI companies want access to that much human conversation, they may have to pay up too.

And that would nearly all be pure profit for Reddit.

And I would say a login wall is going to make Reddit much harder to scrape, which definitely should give it more leverage at the negotiating table, at least with these AI companies.

Yeah, I think while that international expansion you just went over is very, very nice, I also think the gap between the US and international revenue per user will never fully close.

So we mentioned that advertisers in the US know that the US customers are just more valuable. But I also don't think it needs to really close. So if international revenue per user just doubles over five years while those users keep growing, well, then that's an enormous amount of revenue requiring almost no capital.

Still, it's important to remember that the US ad pricing is doing most of the heavy lifting right now. Management had guided to about 48% growth this quarter and delivered 53%.

So the beat was real, but next quarter's guide is closer to 40%, and the user count could shrink. And that combination I think is what sent the stock down about a quarter in a day.

Still, a business growing 40% plus with a 90% plus gross margins and no debt isn't really telling me that it's a business that's in a lot of trouble. Back in my first pitch, the big question was whether Reddit would turn out more like Meta or more like Snapchat, and we've covered that today, and I think it's been clearly answered.

I assumed operating margins could also climb to around 30% by the end of the decade, and Reddit got there in less than two years. So they made me look very bearish, and revenue per user, especially in the US, has grown much, much faster than I expected.

So on monetization, I was way too conservative, wildly too conservative.

Where I have, at least at the moment, seemed to be too optimistic was on the user growth side. And so I treated Google as a fairly reliable on and off again tailwind, and I even said at the time that Reddit wasn't entirely dependent on Google, and that's still true for revenue, but clearly not for users.

And that's the assumption I would probably need to mark down.

So I'm not going to throw out a precise number today because, frankly, the range of outcomes has gotten a lot wider, and that makes it really a lot harder to value the company exactly.

And I'm still, honestly, digesting a lot of the news of this most recent quarter's results and the tension with Google.

But what I can tell you is my thinking has changed in some ways, right? And so I'm assuming slower user growth, especially from logged out traffic, leaning more on pricing and the logged in core of users.

And then I wanted to use a lower valuation multiple to reflect the increased uncertainty for where the business might trade five years from now.

If you put that together, my sense of fair value is definitely lower than it was a year ago, but at the same time below $100 per share. Personally, I'm a happy buyer.

Yeah, fair enough. So with Reddit generating about billion dollars a year in cash flow, I think the answer on whether the company is more like Meta or Snapchat is very very clear as you already kind of pointed out there.

But I think the counterintuitive part is that a business can massively beat your expectations and its value can still move less than you'd think because the market was already pricing in a lot of that success.

And after this quarter, I think the big question isn't next year's number. It's what's Reddit going to look like 10 years from now if Google keeps sending fewer and fewer people its way.

The good news again is that around that $100 share price, I don't think you need heroic assumptions in any of your financial modeling. Once you strip out the cash and the stock-based comp, you're really paying something like a low 20s multiple of what I would call owner's earnings for a business that is still guiding to 40% growth with the point being the story should speak for itself really.

20s multiple of what I would call owner's earnings for a business that is still guiding to 40% growth with the point being the story should speak for itself really. I mean, if Reddit keeps growing its logged-in users and keeps getting more out of each ad, I think that will do more than enough to drive earnings growth and you won't need to bet on the market falling back in love with the stock.

And I guess the question is where that leaves us. For me, I'm probably the most optimistic of me, you, and and Daniel on Reddit. So I'm I'm a bit more inclined to pull the trigger when I see Reddit trading at 17 times operating profit.

But I also recognize that there are huge question marks around the company's growth. So if you are thinking that you want to pass on the company or pass on adding to our position in the company, for the moment I I certainly don't follow you for that.

Yeah, thanks Sean. And I think I really like Reddit and we talked a lot about this kind of before the episode. And I think it's a really good business. Sean ended up going even more into detail about what he liked and where he thought this business could go.

And I still think it's in a really really good position.

I still do think though even with this really good growth number that it has, there's still just a lot of questions for me. And you know, Sean definitely knows the business more.

So I actually think from his perspective and from probably the intrinsic value portfolio's perspective, it probably just makes sense just to leave the position alone.

Perhaps I think Sean also insinuated that next quarter given the fact that management insinuated that numbers are probably going to be even uglier. There might be even a chance to add even more at a much lower price.

I will say that I am very very interested in this business. I think I probably need to spend a little more time, maybe actually just logging on and getting a better feel for it so I can hopefully somewhat approach uh I don't think I'll ever actually approach Sean's understanding of the business, but at least get closer to it because I do think that it's a very very compelling opportunity.

Well, that's all we have for you today folks and as usual I want to leave you with a quote and this one is from Reddit's founder and CEO Steve Huffman. If they take our content and build businesses on it, that's an issue.

If they build businesses such that people come to Reddit less, that's an issue. Now this quote came out 3 years later and I think that quote reads almost like a prediction of what's happening today.

Reddit definitely solved the first problem by getting paid for its data, but the second one, people coming to Reddit less is exactly what showed up in this quarter's numbers and going logged in only is Huffman's bet that he can solve that one too.

Watchpoints

logged-in and international user growth in the logged-in-only test, reported in the next Q4 earnings report

What this channel has said about $RDDT

The Intrinsic Value Podcast has 2 calls on this stock; only the adjacent ones are shown.

TickerSays