$AMD · Parkev Tatevosian, CFA · 2026-11-15
AMD 估值偏高,在当前价格下他会选择 Nvidia 而非 AMD。尽管预计未来几年 AMD 每股收益年增长约 70%,而 Nvidia 为 50%,且其 17.7% 的营业利润率应会上升,而 Nvidia 65% 的优势将在未来十年收窄,但 Nvidia 在多数指标上仍占主导。他无法认同 AMD 以三倍于 Nvidia 的估值交易,称这一估值并不合理、由情绪驱动;他按现金流折现估算的合理价值约 390 美元,而股价为 533 美元,这印证了估值偏高。
播放时,YouTube 可能接收设备与播放信息并使用 Cookie。 隐私说明 · Google 隐私政策
逐段跳播
既然 Jenson Huang 已正式离开 Nvidia,同样的问题又出现了:投资 Nvidia 还是 AMD,哪个更好?
Now that Jenson Huang has officially left Nvidia, the same question arises again: which is better to invest in, Nvidia or AMD ?
讽刺的是,在 Nvidia 董事会寻找新 CEO 之际,我认为最佳人选是来自 AMD 的 Lisa Su。我认为 Lisa Su 不太可能被从 AMD 挖走,但在我看来,她是 Nvidia 能争取到的 CEO 最佳人选之一。
Ironically, while Nvidia's board is looking for a new CEO, I think the best candidate is Lisa Su from AMD. I think it's unlikely Lisa Su will be lured away from AMD, but in my opinion she's one of the best candidates Nvidia could get for the CEO position.
但既然 Jenson Huang 已经离开,现在让我们把这两家公司正面比较一下,判断在当前市场价格下哪一家看起来是更有吸引力的买入机会。
But let's compare these two companies head-to-head now that Jenson Huang has left, to determine which one looks like a more attractive buying opportunity at current market prices.
事实上,相比 Nvidia,AMD 未来几年的每股收益增长前景更好。
In fact, AMD has better growth prospects for earnings per share over the next few years compared to Nvidia.
其中一个主要原因是,AMD 花了更长时间才实现数据中心支出的收益。AMD 的图形处理器(GPU)花了一些时间才赶上 Nvidia,但 AMD 的产品现在正变得越来越有竞争力。
One of the main reasons for this is that AMD took longer to realize the benefits of spending on data centers. AMD's graphics processing unit (GPU) took some time to catch up with Nvidia, but AMD's unit is now becoming increasingly competitive.
多年来我一直认为,AMD 是一家出色的第二名公司。在21世纪头十年的大部分时间里,他们在中央处理器(CPU)领域相比 Intel 排名第二,做得非常出色。
I have argued for many years that AMD is a great company in second place. They did a great job of ranking second in the field of central processing units (CPUs) compared to Intel during the better part of the first decade of the 21st century.
在用于个人电脑的游戏图形处理器领域,他们相比 Nvidia 位居第二,同样做得非常出色。
They also did a great job in second place compared to Nvidia in graphics processing units designed for gaming that are placed inside personal computers.
我认为,在图形处理器方面,他们作为仅次于 Nvidia 的第二大数据中心供应商会做得非常出色,而他们作为紧随其后的第二大供应商也确实做得很好。
I would argue that they would do a great job as the second-largest data center provider in terms of graphics processing units compared to Nvidia, and they have done a great job being that close second-largest provider.
这使 AMD 的市场份额在数据中心热潮中不断增长。另外,从2026年开始,我们看到智能体 AI 的扩散,这使得中央处理器(CPU)在数据中心中的存在变得更加重要。
This has led to AMD's market share growing amid the data center boom. Also, starting in 2026, we saw the spread of agentic AI, which made the presence of the central processing unit (CPU) in the data center more important.
中央处理器(CPU)是 AMD 主导的品类,这一领域的日益普及帮助增强了 AMD 的业务及其订单积压。那么,展望未来,华尔街分析师预计 AMD 的每股收益在未来几年将每年增长70%。
The central processing unit (CPU) is a category dominated by AMD, and the increasing prevalence of this sector has contributed to strengthening AMD's business and its backlog of orders.
So, looking ahead now, Wall Street analysts expect AMD's earnings per share to grow by 70% annually over the next few years.
这是一个极好的增长率,只是与 AMD 的每股收益预期相比才显得小。我接下来想比较这两家公司的另一个方面是营业利润率,在过去十年的大部分时间里,Nvidia 在这方面的表现明显优于它们。
This is an excellent rate of increase, and it only seems small in comparison with AMD's earnings per share estimates. The next thing I wanted to compare these two companies on was operating profit margin, where Nvidia has significantly outperformed them for most of the past decade .
Nvidia 过去十二个月的营业利润率达到65%,而 AMD 仅为17.7%。展望未来,我预计这一差距会缩小。
Nvidia achieved an operating profit margin of 65% over the past twelve months, compared to just 17.7% for AMD. Looking ahead, I expect this gap to narrow.
因此,Nvidia 的营业利润率趋势在未来几年很可能保持持平或处于低位,而 AMD 的利润率趋势很可能从当前时点起上升,因为它一直是从一个相对较低的水平往上升的。
Therefore, Nvidia's operating profit margin trend is likely to remain flat or low in the coming years, while AMD's profit margin trend is likely to rise from this point onward, as it has been rising from a relatively low level .
要记住,在某个时点、某个时刻,它的营业利润率在12个月期间曾转为负值。所以,这是一个 Nvidia 拥有显著优势的类别,但我认为这一优势在未来几年会减弱。
Remember that at some point, at a certain moment, its operating profit margin turned negative over a 12-month period. So, this is a category where Nvidia has a significant advantage, but I think that advantage will diminish over the next few years.
不过,我认为在未来十年的大部分时间里,Nvidia 仍会保持对 AMD 的优势,但我预计这一优势会缩小。在人均营收方面,我一直保持着对 AMD 的优势。这大约是 AMD 人均营收117万美元的五倍。
However, I think Nvidia will retain its advantage over AMD for most of the next decade, but I expect that advantage to shrink . I have always maintained an advantage over AMD in terms of revenue per employee.
This is roughly five times AMD's revenue per employee of $1.17 million.
该公司在人均营收方面没有显示出任何放缓的迹象,而且当我们审视 Nvidia 和 AMD 双方的轻资产商业模式时,有理由认为它们能够维持这些高水平;因为当它们的业务蓬勃发展时,并不需要在制造人员上花更多钱。
The company has shown no signs of slowing down in terms of revenue per employee, and when we look at the asset-light business model of both Nvidia and AMD, it is reasonable to assume that they can maintain these high levels; Because when their businesses are thriving, they don't need to spend more on manufacturing staff.
你不需要在那些需要大额支出和高成本的类别上花更多钱。它们不需要不断增加工程师来实现企业部门收入的扩张。这就是投资者群体如此被 Nvidia 和 AMD 吸引的原因,因为它们有能力在不花很多钱的情况下实现高速增长。
You don't need to spend more money in categories that require large expenditures and high costs. They do not need to increasingly hire additional engineers to achieve an expansion in enterprise sector revenues.
This is why the investor community was so attracted to Nvidia and AMD, because of their ability to soar without having to spend a lot.
所以,在我们考察的大多数类别中,Nvidia 都胜过 AMD,而且不只是小幅领先,而是大幅领先。
So, in most of the categories we looked at, Nvidia outperformed AMD, not just by a small amount, but by a significant amount.
除了未来几年的每股收益,AMD 在这一项上比 Nvidia 高出约40%,预期每股收益为70%,而 Nvidia 为50%,这是由于其基数规模与 Nvidia 相比所致。
Except for earnings per share over the next few years, where AMD outperforms Nvidia by about 40%, with an expected earnings per share of 70% compared to 50% for Nvidia, due to the size of its base compared to Nvidia.
所以,看到 AMD 的估值是 Nvidia 的三倍,我感到很意外。我认为这凸显了投资者情绪。投资者一直对 AMD 极为乐观。
So it's surprising to me to see AMD trading at a valuation three times that of Nvidia. I think this highlights investor sentiment. Investors have been extremely optimistic about AMD.
2026年投资者对 AMD 股票的情绪非常高,但2026年对 Nvidia 的情绪却非常负面,而且在 CEO 的消息传出后更是雪上加霜。
Investor sentiment towards AMD stock was very high in 2026, but it was very negative for Nvidia in 2026, and even worse since the CEO news broke.
不管原因是什么,Nvidia 股票目前的估值只相当于 AMD 的三分之一,仅仅是 AMD 的三分之一。我觉得这么高的评级对 AMD 来说并不应得。
Regardless of the reason, Nvidia's stock is trading at a valuation equivalent to one-third of AMD's , just one-third of AMD's. I feel that this high rating is undeserved for AMD.
Nvidia 在大多数指标上占据主导地位,其业务在竞争优势方面也处于领先,尽管随着 AMD 的 GPU 不断改进并缩小与 Nvidia 的差距,这一领先优势正在缩小,而且 AMD 的 CPU 比市场上可用于数据中心的 CPU 更好。
Nvidia dominates most metrics, and its business is ahead in terms of competitive advantages , although that lead is shrinking as AMD's GPUs improve and close the gap with Nvidia, and AMD's CPUs are better than what's available on the market for data centers.
因此,AMD 正在努力缩小这一差距。所以,你或许可以说它们应该以相近的估值交易,但我无法为 AMD 相对 Nvidia 高达三倍的估值给出合理依据。
Thus, AMD is working to close the gap. Therefore, you could say that they should be traded at a similar valuation, but I cannot justify the three-fold valuation of AMD compared to Nvidia.
这看起来是投资者群体对 AMD 相对 Nvidia 的显著高估。
This appears to be a significant overvaluation by the investor community regarding AMD versus Nvidia.
我还对 AMD 做了现金流折现估值,估算出该公司股价约为 390 美元。今天,即便 AMD 股价已下跌 9%,其交易价格仍为 533 美元。
I also performed a discounted cash flow valuation for AMD and estimated the value of this company's shares at approximately $390. Today, even after AMD's stock fell by 9% , it is trading at $533.
因此,用这一估算来看,它似乎也被高估了。所以,我现在用了两种不同的估值方法,两者都指向同一个结论:即便把黄仁勋被免去 CEO 职务后引发的动荡和 Nvidia 业绩下滑考虑在内,AMD 股票相对 Nvidia 股票仍然被高估。
Therefore, it seems to be overrated using this estimate as well. So, I have now used two different valuation estimates, and both point to the same conclusion: that AMD stock is overvalued compared to Nvidia stock, even after including the turmoil and Nvidia's declining performance following Jensen Huang's dismissal as CEO.
那么,要回答你应该买入 AMD 股票而不是 Nvidia 股票,还是买入 Nvidia 股票而不是 AMD 股票这个问题,至少对我来说,这是一个相对容易的选择。
Now, to answer the question of whether you should buy AMD stock instead of Nvidia stock or buy Nvidia stock instead of AMD stock, I think it's a relatively easy choice for me at least .
在当前市价下,我会选择 Nvidia 而不是 AMD。但请在下方的评论区告诉我你的想法。我知道投资者对 AMD 股票的情绪非常高,而对 Nvidia 股票的情绪非常低,但我很好奇,想知道你更偏好 AMD 股票而非 Nvidia 的原因,以及为什么 AMD 股票在个人投资者中比 Nvidia 更受欢迎。
I would choose Nvidia over AMD at current market prices . But please tell me what you think in the comments section below. I know that investor sentiment towards AMD stock is very high and towards Nvidia stock is very low, but I am curious to know the reasons for your preference for AMD stock over Nvidia , and why AMD stock is more popular among individual investors compared to Nvidia.
这个频道对 $AMD 的历次判断
Parkev Tatevosian, CFA 在这只股票上共 6 条判断,这里只列相邻的几条。