$MSTR · Benzinga · 2026-11-18
说话者在结构上看空 MSTR(其相对 NAV 溢价 200%,他称之为庞氏骗局),并预计它会像封闭式基金一样以平价或低于平价交易,真正的风险是债务或股息义务无法履行引发的流动性危机。但在相对 NAV 折价 30% 时他不会做空;卖出价外看跌期权风险回报有利,而折价 50% 将是买入机会。
播放时,YouTube 可能接收设备与播放信息并使用 Cookie。 隐私说明 · Google 隐私政策
逐段跳播
我一直没法真正理解 MSTR 的价格。我想知道 Micro Strategy 的股价和比特币的未来之间这种关系到底有多脆弱。泡沫破裂时会发生什么?而泡沫最终总会破裂。MSDR 的交易价格相对其净资产价值有200%以上的溢价。
那我来问你:为什么会有人以低于1%的利率把钱借给 Micro Strategy,去买价格是当前交易价三倍的比特币?这看起来要么是有史以来最厉害的营销手段,要么就是一场睁着眼睛参与的现代版上市庞氏骗局——暗示高回报却几乎或完全没有风险,这恰恰与我们在 Tasty 所教的一切背道而驰。
简单说,风险不是那样运作的。MSDR 策略的关键就是不断加码推高,通过筹集越来越多的资金,同时维持相对比特币实际价格不切实际的溢价。他们实际上永远没法卖出,因为一旦溢价消失、MSDR 相对比特币出现折价交易,他们就会把整个数字资产市场砸崩。
可转债的买方和 MSDR 的投资者都应该小心。如果你喜欢比特币,就直接买比特币。那要便宜得多。
I can't seem to wrap my head around the price of MSTR. I wonder how tenuous the relationship between the price of Micro Strategy and the future of Bitcoin is. What happens when the bubble breaks?
And eventually the bubble always breaks. MSDR trades at a 200% plus premium to its nav. So riddle me this. Why would anyone loan money to Micro Strategy at less than 1% to buy Bitcoin at three times where it's currently trading?
It seems to be either the greatest marketing ploy ever or an eyes wide openen modern-day version of a listed Ponzi scheme implying high returns with little or no risk is the very antithesis of everything we teach at Tasty.
Simply put, risk doesn't work that way. The key to MSDR strategy is constantly fueling the pump by raising more and more capital while maintaining an unrealistic premium over the actual price of Bitcoin.
They literally can never sell because if the premium disappears and MSDR trades at a discount to Bitcoin, they will crash the digital asset marketplace. Convertible bomb buyers and MSDR investors should be careful.
If you love Bitcoin, just buy Bitcoin. It's a hell of a lot less of expensive.
那就是 MSTR,你写那段话时它是360,而今天是92。然后你在2025年6月写过它,称其为庞氏骗局。你还在另一个时间写过它,称其为庞氏骗局。我们还发表过你一次,称其为庞氏骗局。
That's MSTR, which was at 360 when you wrote that. And today it is at 92. And then you wrote about it in June 2025 calling it a Ponzi scheme. And you wrote about it in another time calling it a Ponzi scheme.
And we published you once calling it a Ponzi scheme.
我从 Michael Sailor 那时候起就一直看空 Micro Strategy,而且,而且,而且,而且你要理解一件对我来说很难的事。我非常看好数字领域,看好整个数字生态系统。
所以我看好数字资产。我相信数字资产。我相信代币化。我相信你所知道的那个世界,我相信那个世界会成为未来非常重要的一类资产。我只是无法相信人们竟然会买 Michael Sailor 那套垃圾论点,他们盲目地把钱砸向 Micro Strategy,没有转换率,没有利率。
这就像,我以前也听说过愚蠢的投资,但任何把钱投进 Micro Strategy 的人,那简直就是疯狂。而且,我一直在写,我都不知道我写过多少次。我以前每天写,或者每周写,有时是每天,但那是发给,我不知道,几十万人的通讯,我一年里会好几次持续抨击 Micro Strategy,就是因为我想,我不明白这个。
这完全说不通。在这个等式里,无论是支付100%的溢价、200%的溢价,没有任何一部分对我来说说得通,Adam。这太疯狂了。我觉得它要崩了。
I have been bearish on micro strategies since Michael Sailor and and and and understand something that's so hard for me. I'm very bullish on digital on the whole digital ecosystem.
So, I'm bullish on digital assets. You know, I believe in digital assets. I believe in tokenization. I believe in the world that you know of I I I believe in that world as as being a very important asset class to the future.
I just could not believe that people were buying Michael Sailor's garbage argument and they were blindly throwing money at Micro Strategies with no conversion rates, no interest rates.
It was it was like I've heard of dumb investments before, but anybody that put money into micro strategies was just like it was just insanity. And um I just I I've been writing I don't know how many times I wrote about it.
I used to write it daily, you know, or weekly and sometimes was daily, but um you know, newsletter that went out to I don't know a few hundred thousand people and and I was constantly railing a couple times a year on micro micro strategies just because I'm like I don't get this.
It doesn't make any sense. There's no part of this equation of, you know, paying a 100% premium, a 200% premium, all it just none of it made sense to me, Adam. It was crazy. I feel like it's going to crash.
我不认为,我不知道 Micro Strategy 从这里会怎么走。但他们将面临的挑战是,我的意思是,他们持有大量比特币,最终它会跌到平价,或者它会像一只封闭式基金那样,在略低于平价的位置交易,但我不知道会怎样。
I don't think I don't know what Micro Strategies does from here. But the challenge that they are going to have is that I mean they own a lot of Bitcoin and eventually you know it it'll go to parody or it'll trade it'll trade like a closed end fund just under parody but I don't know how
我没算过这笔账。590亿对400亿的股票市值,意味着32%的折价。对。它以前一度溢价交易到200%。这个市场就是这么疯狂。嗯,对。而 Micro Strategy 现在是折价。
它交易,我一直说它总有一天会像封闭式基金那样交易。而现在它恰恰就像一只封闭式基金在交易。你知道,它在低于平价交易。所以如果你想买比特币,这可能是 Micro Strategy 少数说得通的时机之一。
我的意思是,我不该说如果你想买比特币,但如果你想在那里卖出一个价外看跌期权,这大概是个不差的风险回报比。就目前的风险回报而言,我喜欢那个比例。我只是不喜欢那家公司,但那只是我的交易方式。
那些东西本来就该被卖出,而我现在不会在这里卖,因为它在低于平价交易,而且我看好比特币,所以我现在卖它毫无道理。
I I haven't done the math. 59 billion versus a 40 billion equity market cap implying a 32% discount. Yeah. And it used to trade up to 200% over. Like that's how crazy this market is.
Um Yeah. And Micro Strategies is is a discount. It trades I I always said it's going to trade like a closed end fund someday. And um it's exactly trading like a closed end fund right now.
Like you you know it's trading under parody. So if you want to buy Bitcoin, you know, this might be one of the few times micro strategies make sense. I mean, I shouldn't say if you want to buy Bitcoin, but if you want to sell an out- of- the money put in there, it's probably not a bad riskreward ratio.
Riskreward at this point. I like that ratio. I just don't like that company, but um you know, I mean, that's just how I trade. Those things that deserve to be sold and I wouldn't sell it here because it's under parody, you know, like I mean I'm and I'm bullish on Bitcoin, so it would make no sense for me to sell it here.
等一下。我刚建了一个,我刚做了一个看跌日历价差。我买入了90,卖出了80,12月18日到期。
One sec. I just put on I just went on a bearish calendar. I bought the 90 and sold the 80 for December 18th.
MSTR 现在处于他们所说的自由落体状态。它在自由落体。所以,它们现在的交易,它们现在的价值超过了,所以,现在就是你刚说的那样。现在的情况是,他们说这家有工资支出和其他东西的公司,你知道,一文不值。
MSTR is in freef fall strategy as they call now. It's in freef fall. So, they're trading they're worth now more than So, now you're now it's what you just said. Now it's that they're saying the company with payroll and other things is just, you know, worthless.
对。我的意思是,确实存在真实的风险,你知道,在目前这个时点,比特币之所以这么沉重,原因之一很可能也是 Micro Strategy,因为确实存在他们不得不进入市场、抛售一些比特币之类的真实风险。
Yeah. I mean, there's a real there's a real risk that, you know, at this point, um, one of the reasons that Bitcoin is is so heavy is probably micro strategies, too, because there's a real risk that they're going to have to go into the marketplace, you know, and and dump some, you know, dump some Bitcoin and things like that.
如果他们能够,如果他们被迫卖出,而他们的价值持续下跌,他们真的能,如果他们不得不清算,他们的规模够大吗,真的能砸崩加密市场吗,他们能不能把……
if they could if they're forced to sell and their value keeps going down and they they could really do are they big enough if they had to liquidate to to really like crash the crypto market like could they bring
这是个好问题。人们一直争论,而我认为我就是这些人之一。我过去一直主张,他们有可能,我不太想用“单点故障”这个词,因为我不确定他们会不会成为比特币的单点故障。
That's a great question. They they people have argued and I think I'm one of these people. I've argued in the past that they potentially I I hate to use the term single point of failure because I don't know that they'd be a single point of failure for Bitcoin.
对。我,我,从这个意义上说他们确实让我害怕。但在30%,你会说现在有30%的折价吗?对。在30%的折价下,我认为市场已经,你知道……
Yeah. I I it they do scare me in that sense. But at a 30 would you say a 30% discount right now? Yeah. At a 30% discount I I think the market's already you know
嗯,在 Micro Strategy 这里卖出价外看跌期权,我会比在其他股票上紧张得多。我没有那种同样的恐惧。我不担心 Micro Strategy 在这些价格、在30%折价下的情况。
Um, I I would be a lot less nervous of selling out of the money puts in micro strategies here than than I would be in other stocks. Like I don't have that same fear. I like I'm not, you know, I'm not worried about micro strategies at these at these prices at a 30% discount.
也许它会跌到50%的折价,但即便如此,我的意思是,它会不会成为一只落下的巨大靴子,真的把加密市场搞乱?也许吧。但我觉得那会是一个买入机会。我真的这么认为。
Maybe it goes to 50% discount, but even so, you know, I mean, could it be a giant shoe to drop and and really mess up crypto space? Maybe. But, um, I think that would be a buying opportunity. I really do.
好。我的意思是,我想这只是值得关注的事。我只是很高兴自己没在里面。
Okay. I I mean, just something to watch, I guess. I'm just happy not to be in it.
不,它不是流动性最好的标的,我做空过它一段时间,在里面赚了一点钱,但这不是针对谁。这不是那种我想押上全部身家的东西。只是因为它对我来说流动性不够,而且我真的不想参与那家公司,我不想跟它有任何关系。
所以,是的,我交易过一点,现在还有一个小仓位,但我从来都不是那种特别喜欢交易这只股票的人。
No, it wasn't the most liquid underlying and you know, I was short it for a while and I made a little money in there, but I didn't I didn't it wasn't personal, you know? You know what I mean?
Like it wasn't like something that I wanted to bet the ranch on. I only because I just it wasn't liquid enough for me and I didn't really I just didn't want to be involved in that company, you know?
like I didn't want to have anything to do with it. So, yeah, I traded it a little bit, but I have a small position on in there now, but I I don't I've never been a huge fan of trading that stock.
我现在没法把目光从 Strategy 上移开。它跌了6%,处于当日低点。这可能是——它现在交易在哪里?大概90出头,907、9069,当日低点。看起来像是到头了。我敢说。我的意思是,这看起来——我觉得明天它可能低开20点,比特币跌3万,跌到3万。
I can't take my eyes off strategy right now. It's down 6%. It's at the lows of the day. Like this could be this is this is that where is it trading? Like low 90s $907 $9069 low of the day.
It seems like it's the end. I'm calling it. I mean, this looks like this I feel like this could open down 20 points tomorrow with with Bitcoin down 30 like 30,000.
如果 MSTR 因为如果它们回去如果它们倒闭了,它们将被迫清算,它们并不拥有——我不认为比特币世界里存在杠杆。所以我不认为它们加了杠杆。所以我不认为它们会——我不认为它们必然面临强制清算的风险。它们是全额支付的。
If MSTR because they would be forced to liquidate if they went back if they were out of business, Well, they don't they don't own I I don't think they there's no leverage in Bitcoin in the Bitcoin world.
So I don't think that they're levered. So I don't think that they'd be I don't think there's necessarily a force liquidation risk for them. They pay for it in full.
它们面临的挑战将是:从哪里弄到钱来满足债务要求,我确信它们有大量债务。我不知道那具体是多少,但我不知道它们从哪里弄到钱来支付股息或满足债务要求。所以,这就是它们的挑战。
What their what their challenge is going to be is where do they come up with the money to meet their debt requirements, you know, and I'm sure they have a ton of debt. And I don't know I don't know what that is, but I don't know where they get their their where they get the money to meet their dividend or their debt requirements. So, you know, I mean, that's their challenge.
如果 Strategy 被迫清算其比特币持仓,可能引发比特币历史上最剧烈的抛售之一。这里有一个重要区别:MSTR 股价暴跌并不会自动迫使公司卖出比特币。这就是你刚才说的。
if strategy were forced to liquidate its Bitcoin holdings, it could trigger one of the most violent sell-offs in Bitcoin history. There's an important distinction. MSDR stock collapsing does not automatically force the company to sell Bitcoin. That's what you just said.
真正的危险将是流动性危机,即 Strategy 无法再履行其财务义务,不得不开始出售其比特币储备。以下是分析。小规模清算,持仓的5%到10%,对比特币有5%到12%的影响。25%到50%,对比特币有15%到30%的影响。
几乎全部卖出,30%到50%或更糟。他们拥有85万枚比特币,价格为75,452。所以他们拥有比特币供应量的4%。
The real danger would be a liquidity crisis where strategy can no longer meet its financial obligations and had to start selling its Bitcoin treasury. Here are the analysis. Small liquidation, 5 to 10% of holdings, you have a 5 to 12% impact on Bitcoin. 25 to 50% 15 to 30% on Bitcoin.
For sale of virtually everything, 30 to 50% or worse. Uh Bitcoin own they own 850,000 Bitcoin at a price of 75,452. So they own 4% of the Bitcoin supply.
我一直认为这是一个庞氏骗局,但我不希望他们扼杀比特币市场,因为我认为数字资产领域有太多好事发生。
I thought it was a Ponzi scheme all along, but I don't want them to kill the Bitcoin market because I think there's too much good that happens in the world of digital assets.
三年前,你在 MSTR 股价360的时候谈论过它会下跌。现在你说你会买入它,这说得通。我坐在这里说:“哦,让我们在最糟糕的时机做空它。”我忍不住,因为现在看起来疲软,这就是你进来的地方。
three years ago, you talked about MSTR going down when it was at 360. And now you're saying you would buy it, which makes sense. I'm sitting here saying, "Oh, let's short it at the worst time possible."
Um, and I can't help it because this is where it looks weak and this is where you come in.
我认为 MSTR 会完蛋,它会——我不是说这是比特币的终结,但我是说会有一场海啸冲击加密货币。从某些东西的交易方式来看,Coinbase 的交易方式,MSTR 的交易方式,Robin Hood 现在的交易方式,很明显市场是害怕的,毫无疑问。
I think MSTR will be done and it will be I'm not saying it's the end of Bitcoin, but I'm saying there will be a sh a like a tsunami to hit crypto. from the way certain things are trading the way Coinbase is trading the way MSDR is trading the way Robin Hood's trading right now there's clearly you know the marketplace is scared um no question about it
Anthropic,你要交易吗?我明天在路上。我不知道它什么时候出来。第一天没什么可做的,因为如果你拿不到任何股票,你能做的,没什么可做的。你不能做空它。除了买入,你什么也做不了。我不会买它。
Anthropic you're going to trade? Um I'm on the road tomorrow. I don't know what time it's coming out. There's not much to do on day one because if you don't get any stock, all you can do, there's nothing you can do.
You can't short it. There's nothing you can do except buy it. I'm not going to buy it.
周五或周一应该有期权。那时我会开始交易它。如果它下跌,表现不佳可能对市场不利。应该是这样。哦,天哪。是的。是的。是的。当然。
There should be options on Friday or Monday. That's when I'll start trading it. If it goes down, it it's that that a bad performance will probably be bad for the market. Should be Oh, god. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. For sure.
你回想一下,甚至三年前、两年前与 MSTR 的那次对话。
and you look back to like even the conversation with MSTR three years ago, two years ago.
标题是 Saznoff 称 Micro Strategy 为庞氏骗局。而如今多年过去,这成了最好的新闻标题,为人们省下了很多钱。所以,谢谢你。
the headline was Saznoff calls Micro Strategy a Ponzi scheme. And now here it is years later. Best headline ever. Save the people a lot of money. So, thank you.
这个频道对 $MSTR 的历次判断
Benzinga 在这只股票上共 7 条判断,这里只列相邻的几条。