$MU · Parkev Tatevosian, CFA · 2026-11-11
相比 TSMC 更看好 Micron:Micron 在景气上行时表现强于 TSMC,尽管在平常时期跑输,因此增长潜力更大但波动也更高。其 3.5 倍市盈率反映了不可持续的峰值 EPS 及其周期性;而他的 DCF——自由现金流增长在 2028-2029 年前后见顶,随后放缓至远低于过去两年的速度——给出公允价值 1,566 美元,对比 729 美元,显著低估。他持有该股。
播放时,YouTube 可能接收设备与播放信息并使用 Cookie。 隐私说明 · Google 隐私政策
逐段跳播
Micron 和 Taiwan Semiconductor 是领先的半导体制造商,在销售额和利润方面都实现了显著增长。
Micron and Taiwan Semiconductor are leading semiconductor manufacturers, experiencing remarkable growth in sales and profits.
这轮繁荣是由人工智能带来的。Micron 生产用于数据中心的存储和存储组件,而 Taiwan Semiconductor 生产的组件范围更广,同样用于数据中心,也用于更广泛的消费电子领域。
This boom is due to artificial intelligence. Micron manufactures memory and storage components used in data centers, while Taiwan Semiconductor manufactures a wider range of components that are also used in data centers, as well as broader sectors of consumer electronics.
两家公司的产品需求都大幅增长,未来几年的产能也几乎已经排满。它们还在努力扩大现有制造业务,以满足这些组件日益增长的需求。
Both companies are experiencing significantly increased demand for their products, and their production capacity has nearly peaked for the next few years . They are also working to expand their current manufacturing operations to meet the growing demand for these components.
面对这轮繁荣,投资者现在想知道这两家公司中哪一家是更好的投资选择。我想通过直接比较两家公司的多项关键财务指标来回答这个问题,并分别评估它们,以判断哪一家在当前市场价格下更具吸引力。
Investors are now wondering which of these two companies is a better investment option in light of this boom. I wanted to answer this question by directly comparing the two companies across a number of key financial indicators, as well as evaluating each to determine which is more attractive at current market prices .
一个重要的考量是,比较跟踪这两家公司的华尔街分析师对今后几年每股收益的预测,尤其是这些预测的变化。尤其值得注意的是 Micron 每股收益预测的大幅波动,过去几年里这些预测出现了剧烈起伏。
今后几年的每股收益预测最高上调了175%,最大下调幅度为15%。
An important consideration is comparing earnings per share estimates for the next few years by Wall Street analysts who follow these two companies, especially changes in those estimates.
Particularly noteworthy are the large fluctuations in Micron's earnings per share estimates, which have seen sharp swings over the past few years. Earnings per share estimates for the next few years have risen by as much as 175%, and fallen by as much as 15%.
我认为,主要原因在于 Micron 的销售和利润繁荣大部分来自售价上涨,而不是产量增加。换句话说,公司卖出的产品数量相同,但价格高得多,有些情况下甚至达到三位数。
I believe the main reason for this is that Micron achieves most of its sales and profit boom as a result of higher selling prices, not increased production. In other words, the company sells the same quantity of products, but at much higher prices, reaching three figures in some cases.
在某些季度,公司产品价格同比上涨了300%到400%。
In some quarters, the company saw its product prices rise by between 300% and 400% compared to the same quarter of the previous year.
然而,Micron 并非如此。Micron 在景气高峰期能实现更高的平均售价,而在衰退期价格则更低。不过,由于它最近与客户签订了长期合同,这种波动性很可能已经降低。
Micron, however, is not like that. Micron achieves higher average selling prices during peak periods and lower prices during recessions. However, this volatility is likely to have decreased due to the long-term contracts it recently entered into with its clients.
当然,正如预期的那样,客户对于不得不支付比上一年高得多的价格感到不满。但多年来,客户一直把能够买到 Micron 组件或任何存储组件视为理所当然。他们往往拖到几乎最后一刻才下单,然后不得不接受当时市场上的任何价格。
Of course, as expected, customers were upset about having to pay much higher prices compared to the same prices they had paid the previous year. But for many years, customers took for granted their ability to purchase Micron components or any memory or storage components.
They would wait until almost the last minute to place their orders, and then they would have to pay whatever price was prevailing in the market at that moment.
如今,随着供需形势突然变化,客户开始签订长期合同,这为他们保证了固定价格,不是固定价格。Micron 解释说,客户的做法是锁定一个价格区间,即他们愿意支付的最高价和最低价。
Now, following this sudden change in the supply and demand situation, customers are entering into long- term contracts, which guarantee them fixed prices, not fixed prices. Micron explained that what its customers are doing is securing a price range, a minimum and maximum price they will pay.
这并不能提供100%的保证,但可以减少 Micron 客户前几年经历的那种波动。
This does not provide a 100% guarantee, but it reduces the fluctuations that Micron customers have experienced in previous years.
相比之下,Micron 的营业利润率出现了剧烈波动,2024年降至-40%,而在过去十二个月达到75%。有意思的是,在我全职从事这份工作近十年、跟踪过的数百家公司中,我还没见过一家公司报告的营业利润率超过80%。
这种情况一直持续到 Micron 在最近两个季度连续实现这一出色表现,并且现在预计将连续第三个季度实现80%的营业利润率。
In contrast, Micron's operating profit margin has seen sharp fluctuations, falling to -40% in 2024 and reaching 75% in the past twelve months . Interestingly, out of the hundreds of companies I have followed over the nearly decade I have spent in this full-time job, I have not seen a single one that reports an operating profit margin above 80%.
This situation continued until Micron achieved this outstanding performance for two consecutive quarters in the last two quarters, and now expects to achieve an operating profit margin of 80% for the third consecutive quarter.
如你所见,Micron 在景气时期表现优于 Taiwan Semiconductor Company(Taiwan Semiconductor),而在平常时期则落后。
As you can see, Micron outperforms Taiwan Semiconductor Company (Taiwan Semiconductor) in boom times, while it lags behind in normal times.
因此,Micron 的增长潜力更大,但波动性也更大,而 Taiwan Semiconductor 则更稳定。我们会把市盈率作为一个起始指标,但正如我在整个视频中所讨论的,考虑到 Micron 的波动性,这个比率对 Micron 来说意义相对较小。
Therefore, Micron has greater growth potential, but is more volatile, while Taiwan Semiconductor is more stable. We will use the price-to-earnings ratio as a starting indicator, which is a less significant ratio for Micron given what I have discussed throughout this video, namely its volatility.
它的每股收益已达到公司历史上的最高水平,是业绩的顶峰,而这样的每股收益水平是不可持续的。因此,在看市盈率时,我们发现分母是每股收益,而这个比率目前对 Micron 来说高得不可持续。
Its earnings per share have reached an all- time high in the company's history, a peak in performance, and these levels of earnings per share are unsustainable. Therefore, when looking at the price-to-earnings ratio, we find that the denominator is earnings per share, and this ratio is currently unsustainably high for Micron.
但投资者清楚这一点,并预期每股收益长期将回落到更正常的水平。因此,Micron 的股票正以非常低的价格出售,市盈率为3.5。
But investors are aware of this, and expect earnings per share to return to more normal levels in the long term . As a result, Micron shares are being sold at a very low price, with a price- to-earnings ratio of 3.5.
因此,这两家公司都因与其业务活动相关的一个关键因素而以折价出售。Micron 的股票因其周期性而以折价出售。因此,对 Micron 来说,我构建的现金流折现估值模型对我更有用,在进行公司估值分析时,相比市盈率,我更看重这一估值。
Therefore, both companies are sold at a discount due to a key factor related to their business activity. Micron shares are sold at a discount due to their cyclical nature. Therefore, for Micron, the discounted cash flow valuation model I developed is more useful to me, and I give more importance to this valuation when conducting a company valuation analysis compared to the price-to- earnings ratio.
基于这些计算,公司的盈利能力和现金流折现模型仍然考虑了我预期公司在非常长期内将产生的现金流规模。在估算这一现金流时,我考虑到自由现金流的增长不会像过去两年那样高。
Based on these calculations, the company's profitability and discounted cash flow model still take into account the amount of cash flow I expect the company to generate in the very long run .
In estimating this cash flow, I took into account that free cash flow will not grow as much as it has over the past two years.
我预计自由现金流增长将在2028年或2029年左右见顶,此后增速将远低于过去两年的历史平均水平。
I expect free cash flow growth to peak around 2028 or 2029, and then grow at a much slower pace than its historical average over the past two years.
尽管增长前景有限,我计算出的公允价值为1556美元,不,是1566美元,而市场价格为729美元。即便用这个指标来看,该股票也显得被显著低估。
Despite limited growth prospects, I calculated the fair value at $1556, or rather $1566, while the market price is $729. Even with this metric, the stock appears significantly undervalued.
但正如我们在比较中看到的,Micron 似乎比 TSMC 更配得上其真实价值。总体而言,这是两家非常优秀的公司,属于世界上最好的制造企业之列。
But as we saw in the comparison, Micron appears to be more deserving of its true value than TSMC. Overall, these are two very excellent companies , among the best manufacturing companies in the world.
所以,如果我必须在两者之间做选择,这个决定并不容易。不过,目前我会选择 Micron 而不是 Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC)。
So, if I had to choose between them, the decision wouldn't be easy. However, I would choose Micron over Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC) at the moment.
事实上,我的投资组合中持有 Micron 的股票,但我还没有持有 TSMC 的股票。
In fact, I own shares in Micron within my investment portfolio, but I do not own shares in TSMC yet.
这个频道对 $MU 的历次判断
Parkev Tatevosian, CFA 在这只股票上共 15 条判断,这里只列相邻的几条。