$HD

The Motley Fool on $HD (Nov 17, 2026)

AI summary · The Motley Fool

Cautious/neutral on HD: results are strong but show no turnaround as housing stays stagnant; comparable sales rose 2.2% while transactions fell 0.5%, so growth came from price, not volume, and no recovery is visible despite post-midterm and below-5-percent 10-year yield optimism. The stock is up about 20% since early October but roughly flat over five years; low expectations may make meeting them look relatively good, yet the speaker sees little potential from here, with possible improvement if buybacks resume. He likes the CFO-to-CEO move as a capital-discipline signal and expects less aggressive acquisitions and continued buybacks and cash generation.

“Disney’s Beat Expectations, Home Depot has a new CEO, and the Defense Company Behind the Grounding”
The Motley FoolPublished Nov 17 · 16 passages

Playing via YouTube may share device and playback data and use cookies. Privacy Notice · Google Privacy Policy

Jump to any passage

16 passages
8:3615:53

After the break, we'll discuss another company whose current expectations aren't very high, and that's Home Depot. Among the companies whose expectations are not very high right now, Home Depot released its earnings report today.

The share price is down about 2% at the time of recording.

Matt, this is an industry where Home Depot is not responsible for many things. The housing industry is largely stagnant. They are more or less an indicator of the housing industry, where some might argue that Disney's problems are largely of their own making.

So, have there been any signs of recovery or any structural changes in the housing sector in the latest quarter? Because we can usually get a good idea of ​​this by looking at Home Depot's earnings report.

Yes, Home Depot gives you insight into all aspects of the housing sector. It's not just home builders who give an idea of ​​the state of the new home market. Redfin is no longer an independent company, but real estate companies like Zillow will give you an idea of ​​how older homes are selling.

Mortgage companies will show you how people are refinancing their loans. Home Depot does all three of these things. Their pro -business has been a major growth tool for them in the last few years , primarily working with contractors and those building homes.

Their store's sales depend largely on how willing people are to take capital out of their homes. If people plan to spend $50,000 on a kitchen renovation, in most cases they take that money from the equity in the home.

This is no longer happening due to the current interest rate situation. In short, Home Depot's results, while strong, show no signs of turning around.

The share price has risen about 20 percent since the beginning of October. A large part of this was the aftermath of the midterm elections. The Democratic Party generally works in favor of affordable housing, so this happened.

There was a lot of optimism about this after the election. However, in reality, nothing has changed in terms of statistics yet. Sales increased by 2.2 percent, which is a comparable figure.

The number of products per transaction decreased by 0.5 percent compared to last year. This means that people are actually buying fewer goods, and growth is coming from price increases, not from buying more goods.

The short answer to your question is, no, we are not seeing any recovery in the housing sector yet.

Investors were probably hoping for a recovery in the housing sector in the near future, as 10-year bond yields had fallen below 5 percent even before the midterm elections. We have seen interest rates decrease slightly.

This is probably what fueled the optimism and pulled Home Depot out of its slump. But at the same time, we don't see its reflection in the statistics. There is no guarantee whether the midterm elections will ultimately be helpful for the housing sector.

You are right, we are waiting for good news from the housing sector, but we are not seeing any change yet. What we saw in the case of Disney is very similar to this situation. Since expectations are very low , at least meeting that goal can bring relatively good results.

I know the share price is down 2%, but looking at the recent earnings report , this isn't the worst result we've seen.

Yes, the stock has basically stood in the same place over the last 5 years , which Matt explained a little earlier , is quite remarkable in this situation. And I have a theory about this.

I think investors are giving this company a bit of a discount, and that's probably reasonable. Investors trust this business. They know it is linked to the housing sector. They know that the market doesn't have many alternatives.

They know that when the housing sector turns around or interest rates fall, Home Depot will do well again , so they hold onto the shares despite much adversity and volatility. I think we saw that.

We have seen many times in the past that a large part of their income came because their growth period was almost over. I think they've added 15 stores in the last year, but if you look at the number of shares...they buy back their shares.

The number of shares has decreased by 17% over the past decade, but interestingly, it has increased slightly since the beginning of 2024. They made some agreements. They were also doing some other work.

So I don't think there's much potential from here, we're not seeing any signs yet that the housing sector has picked up again. I don't think the housing sector is back , but there is potential for improvement from here.

Maybe when they come out of these deals , maybe they will start buying back shares again and that will help push the stock up.

Loot, I agree with your concession point. Historically, Home Depot has been great at what they do and they have found ways to expand their business. What has happened in the last few years under CEO Ted Decker has been acquisitions, especially in the area of ​​professional contractors.

But keeping that concession in mind , we also saw that CEO Ted Decker, who was on leave for health reasons, has officially stepped down today or this morning, and CFO Richard McPhail will take over as full-time CEO starting November 23.

I find the subject quite interesting, because again, that attitude of giving concessions, the corporate culture, and the issue of promoting employees. I don't know. I think a semiconductor company should have learned something from this recent incident.

I think this could be a move for them , especially since McPhail was the CFO who approved many of these types of contractor acquisitions. Could we maybe be a little more acquisition-oriented , per your point Lou, as a competitor to Brad Jacobs' idea of ​​combining building products and contractors ?

Uh, is there any chance the company will go this route ?

Maybe there is, but I disagree for a few reasons. First of all, yes, McPhail was the CFO who agreed, but I've never seen a CFO who was very enthusiastic about capital spending like this.

Usually, they are the calmest people in the party. So I don't know how interested he is in acquisitions like he was in the past. Secondly, I think it was never a roll-up that they were doing.

They were simply trying to gain exposure in different areas so that they could offer a fuller set of products to customers. They've pretty much done it. So now it will be a little difficult to make acquisitions or increase market share just for the sake of acquisitions.

I think the chances of general acquisitions are much lower now than strategic acquisitions. And finally, the market didn't really like these deals, they liked things like share repurchases.

So I don't know if there's enough interest among investors to be very aggressive right now. I bet the last few years have been the exception and we're back to the familiar and beloved Home Depot where they're steadily buying back shares and generating cash.

Matt, do you believe this? I've said before that pro business is the fastest growing part of the business. He led two major pro acquisitions. Lu is right , the market didn't like them at the time , but it was a good strategy.

But I like this signal because Richard McPhail has not been running the day-to-day operations of Home Depot recently , as Ted Decker has been on leave since August. Um, he's basically just looking at financial matters.

And when you make your finance chief the CEO, although in the case of Nvidia it's not a permanent change, it's an interim thing. This is a permanent change. When you make your finance chief CEO, you send a signal to the market that capital discipline is much more important than operations right now.

Home Depot's operations are continuing smoothly. They are doing a really good job in difficult circumstances. But on the financial side, capital discipline, cost control, strategic acquisitions that are financially profitable, and margin retention—these are all needed in a challenging housing environment that has no end in sight.

So I'm liking this move. I don't think we'll see any over-zealous acquisition strategies. I agree with Lu about what we've seen in the last few years. McPhail has been CFO since 2019 and has a very good track record of maintaining capital discipline beyond acquisitions, and I expect that to continue.

I've said before that pro business is the fastest growing part of the business. He led two major pro acquisitions. Lu is right, the market didn't like them at the time, but it was a good strategy.

But I like this signal because Richard McPhail has not been running the day-to-day operations of Home Depot recently, as Ted Decker has been on leave since August. Um, he's basically just looking at financial matters.

Watchpoints

resumed share repurchases in Home Depot's quarterly report
TickerSays