$MA

Parkev Tatevosian, CFA on $MA (Nov 18, 2026)

AI summary · Parkev Tatevosian, CFA

Mastercard's rise from $470 to about $661 and a 28.5 forward P/E near its highest since 2024 make it no longer a buying opportunity, so the rating is cut from buy to hold; at $661 it exceeds the speaker's $573 intrinsic value and margin of safety and he prefers cheaper names, though he is not selling, the business is excellent, and he may upgrade to buy if the price stays near these levels while performance improves.

He framed it in months
“Why Am I Downgrading This Hall of Fame Stock?”
Parkev Tatevosian, CFAPublished Nov 18 · 18 passages

Playing via YouTube may share device and playback data and use cookies. Privacy Notice · Google Privacy Policy

Jump to any passage

18 passages
0:005:29

Mastercard's stock soared from 470 to 660 in just a few months. And of course, I am happy about that . I own Mastercard shares in my investment portfolio. I've owned it for years.

I have rated Mastercard stock as a buy opportunity several times throughout this year. But today, after the stock price has risen significantly, I am downgrading Mastercard's stock rating .

I no longer believe it is an opportunity to buy at these levels.

Let me share with you the valuation figures that led me to downgrade Mastercard's stock rating from buy to hold.

You can see Mastercard's stock price movement here in 2026, where it is trading at $661 after rising another 1.3% today.

It fell to a low of $470 per share in June. Since then, it has risen sharply to over $661. Overall, the stock has risen more than 15.8% since the beginning of the year plus dividends, outperforming the S&P 500 with less risk.

It has been one of the best performing stocks not only this year, but going back several years. It is one of the best performing stocks in my investment portfolio. I've held Mastercard shares , oh, I'd say since 2020.

Looking ahead, Wall Street analysts have become more optimistic about Mastercard, certainly. They now expect earnings per share to grow by 16.7% over the next few years. This represents an increase from around 13% in mid- 2025.

Revenue growth is approaching double digits, and earnings per share are growing at an even faster pace . One of the main reasons that attracted me to Mastercard stock is the limited competition with its biggest rival, Visa.

In fact, the competition between it and Visa is so limited that they have been accused of collusion and not competing enough, which has attracted the attention of regulators around the world.

Of course, this is a great position to be in as an investor. You like to invest in industries with limited competition. This is not good for traders or consumers because limited competition keeps prices high, but it is good for investors because limited competition improves profitability at the industry level .

Looking at Mastercard's valuation using the forward price-to-earnings ratio, it is now trading at 28.5, which is close to the stock's highest trading level according to this metric since 2024.

The stock has traded at lower valuations at certain moments, and has reached a forward price-to-earnings ratio of 32 at other times. Of course, this is one of the companies I would rank in the "business hall of fame".

Therefore, paying a fair price for such an excellent business is a logical long-term investment decision .

Those limited competitive forces I mentioned earlier have enabled Mastercard to achieve excellent profit margins for a long period. Look at its operating profit margin of 59%. It has remained above or around the 55% level for most of the past decade, and continues to improve .

Similarly, the cash flow from operations to sales ratio was more volatile, but at 46%, it is higher than its level of around 41% in 2017. It is certainly an excellent ratio. Today I also updated my assessment of Mastercard's discounted cash flows, and my analysis of Mastercard today has led to a downgrade of the stock's rating.

I want to be transparent here. I am not interested in selling any of the Mastercard shares I own. I'm just suggesting that it doesn't look like a great buying opportunity at these prices, does it?

I have indeed added more Mastercard shares to my portfolio again this year after establishing my first position in it around 2020.

But now, at approximately $661, the price is exceeding my margin of safety compared to its intrinsic value of $573. So , I don't see the situation as "Oh my God, it's ridiculously expensive."

Let's shoot this arrow and move away. It's just a case of if you're thinking of buying an additional share, I feel there are many other undervalued companies that are trading at ridiculously cheap prices and I'd rather buy them now.

So today I lowered my rating on Mastercard stock to " hold," but I don't expect the business to stay at this level for long. The company is performing exceptionally well, and if the market price stays around these levels and performance improves, it may not be long before I upgrade its rating to a buy opportunity again.

Watchpoints

whether performance improves while the share price stays around current levels

What this channel has said about $MA

Parkev Tatevosian, CFA has 2 calls on this stock; only the adjacent ones are shown.

TickerSays