$NVDA

Aswath Damodaran on $NVDA (Nov 19, 2026)

AI summary · Aswath Damodaran

Nvidia's value before the scandal was about $4.85 trillion against a $5.2 trillion market cap on October 29, slightly overvalued, and the market cap had dropped to $3.6 trillion by November 19. If only short-term effects occur, value falls 5-10%, so $3.6 trillion looks cheap, but long-term damage would hit revenue growth and margins (a 3% growth and 6% margin drop cuts value 24%). If a competent replacement CEO is found, Jensen stays involved, management is strong and the China story is overblown, the market recovers from $3.6 trillion to a higher but possibly sub-$5.2 trillion level; if the process turns ugly and the China scandal has legs, the value drop worsens.

He framed it in weeks
“The Value of Human Frailty: Nvidia faces a Jensen Test!”
Aswath DamodaranPublished Nov 19 · 44 passages

Playing via YouTube may share device and playback data and use cookies. Privacy Notice · Google Privacy Policy

Jump to any passage

44 passages
0:1032:24

the last few weeks, your experience with Jenin Wong and Nvidia should have laid those doubts to rest. I think the biggest story of all has been the fall from grace of Jensen Wong.

more stories came out about affairs with uh his with Nvidia employees who reported to him. And that's a violation of corporate rules. That last week culminated with Nvidia's board asking for Jensen Wong to resign and he stepped down.

you've had the CEO of one of the largest companies in the world a company that's central to the AI story step down. What does it mean for Nvidia's value?

So file that away because I'm going to come back and use this framework to think about where Nvidia is right now.

Jensen Wong added value at Nvidia. not only was the the founder of Nvidia 1993, but he's he's basically created a company that reflects it. It's opportunistic, ambitious, aggressive, and especially over the last 5 years as Invidia has been at the center of the AI boom, he's become a superstar.

In many ways, what Nvidia has done has been a case study of how a company keeps a chain going by financing the companies because remember Nvidia sells the chips that go into the AI building boom.

They want the AI builders to keep doing it. And much of what gets called circular financing is the debt and equity that Nvidia has offered to those companies to keep going.

The first story broke on October 29th. There was a story about Jensen's affair with Alice Wong at Megaspe which is you know which is connections with China. So it brought in both the personal foibless of Jensen Wong with a security concern.

In the following week the story expanded that he had affairs with employees who work for at Nvidian reporting which is a violation of corporate rules.

A few days later the White House chimed in because Nvidia is so central to the US economy. And by the end of last week on November 12th, Jensen Wongut stepped down as CEO.

Since then, he's had second thoughts, but he stepped down. The naming of Colette Crest, who's Nvidia's CFO, has not quelled the scandal. In fact, uncertainties continued to mount.

Starting October 29 29th, which is the day the story broke when Nvidia's market cap was close to 5.2 2 trillion through November 19th, Nvidia has lost $1.5 trillion. Trillion dollars in market cap. This is an Nvidia story.

Clearly the market is reacting to the Jensen Wong story and it's reacting to the uncertainties right like what I can think of at least five uncertainties.

The first is who will replace Jensen as CEO and you have a bunch of names in the mix. Some of them come in with experience in the semiconductor chip business. Some of them work at Nvidia.

Some of them are outsiders with reputations. Tim Cook is a name thrown in there.

We need to know who will replace him. That's one uncertainty. The second is assuming a replacement CEO is found. The question is, will it be somebody that Jensen Wong can work with in the future?

It's more benign if we can find a scenario where Jensen Wong stays around Nvidia is willing to work with the new CEO. We don't know that yet until the new a new CEO is spec.

The third is we're going to get a test of how strong the management team is at Nvidia that Jensen has built because this company will need to be run by that second tier of management at least in the near term and until the new CEO finds his feet.

And of course hanging over the wild card here is the China story because if that China story has legs, Alice Wong is in fact connected to the Chinese government and Nvidia has been playing fast and loose with the rules and not selling chips to China.

This problem gets much bigger because you have sanctions and legal hearings and and consequences that go well beyond a management change.

And hovering over over all of this is another uncertainty that we thought we'd put to rest on November 12th when Jensen Wong stepped down, which is last week and early this week, talks started to mount that maybe there's a way back for him.

Initially, it came from big investors in Nvidia saying, "We'd like Jensen back. He's too critical to the company." But just a couple of days ago, he added his words to the mix, saying, "No, if they wanted him back, he'd be willing to do it."

So let's step back and think about Invidia pre-scandal, and then look at what the scandal can do to the value. As I mentioned, the company's been around since 93, went public in 99. It's always been a very good chip company.

In fact, when I first valued Nvidia, I valued as an opportunistic chip company, a company capable of finding new markets for chips and getting there before everybody else. It did with gaming, it did with crypto, and of course, it did with AI.

It went into superstar status when AI took off in 2022.

So, CEO clearly matters and Jensen Wong's been a big part of this story. Has he been an incredibly effective and extraordinary CEO? I don't think even his critics would deny him that.

He's been an amazing CEO and Nvidia would not be the company it is today without him at the helm.

Now, of course, when you listen to the debate about whether you should come back as a CEO, it's centered on that. He's been an amazing CEO and without him, what will Invidia do?

So, those who who oppose the board want him coming back. You know, their argument is without Jensen Wong, Invidia loses too much value. Those in support of the board's decision say, "Look, you can't let Jensen get away with this because it's a flagrant violation of corporate policy.

And if you throw in the security lapse and the China issue, it becomes far more than that."

I was in I bought Nvidia in 2018 and I did it not because of AI or seeing it coming but because I just felt it was undervalued. It had dropped a lot at that time and it looked cheap to me and I bought it and I got incredibly lucky.

AI took off, Nvidia took off and over the last two to three years I've sold my Nvidia position 25% of the time. So by the start of this year, Nvidia was no longer in my portfolio.

And I've got a lot of blowback on that on how much money I've left in the table. So what I want to to give up front is I like Nvidia. I think I think it's an amazing company. I just didn't like the price it was trading at.

So I went back to October 29th and I valued Nvidia with Jensen Wong still CEO and no scandal on the horizon. And my value is dramatically higher than the value that I got two years ago, three years ago.

And part of the reason is this company has shown an amazing capacity to keep scaling up even though it's a big company from 200 billion to 300 billion revenues while preserving some of the highest profit margins I've seen at a large company.

In fact, if id valued Nvidia in late October, given that it had almost a doubling of revenues in the year leading in, I know this high revenues coming forward and essentially with high revenue growth, the margins they have, even as the AI building boom starts to ease, the value I would have got for the equity in the company would have been close to $4.85 trillion.

On October 29th, before the story broke, Invett was trading at about 5.2 trillion. So, it's slightly overvalued, but still within shouting distance. On November 19th, the market cap had dropped to 3.6 trillion.

You think, okay, this is an incredible bargain. Now, it's 3.6 trillion pricing. The value is at 4.8 trillion, but remember that value is prejensen Wong scandal. So the question then becomes what will this scandal cost Nvidia or put differently does it cost 25 30 35% of its value because that's what the market seems to have brought in.

What are the short-term effects? It might and I but I think it's very unlikely that some of Nvidia's customers might come back to Nvidia and say we're canceling our orders. The reason I don't think it's likely is the customers need Nvidia chips more than Nvidia needs a customer.

So I don't think you're going to see that happen.

Second, and this I think is probably likely to happen is if you get a new CEO, that transition period will mean that things get delayed. Even if it's a great CEO, you don't hit the ground running and make decisions right away. those delays might cost them revenues or create costs in the short term and then of course that wild card of the China story is going to play out and the legal and legislative blowback from that can affect growth and margins in the near term.

My gut feeling is if all you have are short-term effects, the percentage change in value should be contained by you know and I'll give you a way of checking this out. I get about 5 to 10% drop in value from the 4.8 8 trillion which would mean that at 3.6 trillion it looks cheap but there potentially could be long-term effects and the long-term effects show up in two places and these are the two key inputs.

One is as a drop in revenue growth and the other is as a drop in margin. So everything you think of as a consequence is going to show up in one of those two places. I don't think it's a risk effect.

So the cost of capital and failure rate are unaffected. I don't think it's a reinvestment effect. It's really a growth and margin effect.

Here I've calculated how much the value of Nvidia would change if long-term growth and long-term margins change. So as an example, if you have a 3% drop in re grow drop in revenue growth and a 6% drop in margins, Nvidia's value drops by 24%.

The first is will Jensen Wong return? I know that Kalshi right now is putting an estimate of a 10% chance. Will he return? And if he does return, the value is not going to bounce back to 4.8 trillion because the China part of the story is still there.

Second, if he is replaced, how good will the replacement be? You see, how do we measure that? Well, I think the board is looking at people who have both technical expertise in the chief business as well as leadership experience.

So the names you see out there including Colette Cres the interim CEO or and Ian Buck they're Nvidia employees who know the company CEOs of other chip companies Renee H Lisa Sue and I've heard Tim Cook's name thrown in the mix right why it's the leadership abilities the board's balancing technical expertise with leadership skills

and I'm no in no position to tell the board what to do but my advice is that the board should be careful about not mismatching. It's they want to see your reflects where Nvidia is and at the risk of getting some blown back.

I don't think Tim Tim Cook even if you're willing to to step in is the right CEO for Nvidia.

I don't think Nvidia is Apple in 2010. So they have to find a mix. I don't envy them the task because how do you step in and replace a legend?

And if replaced, how much will Jensen be willing to work with this replacement? The most benign value effects will be if Jensen is willing to work with the new CEO and provide strategic help and direction and and his connections.

Big part of Nvidia's values come from Jensen's connections with Taiwan semi and these are personal connections.

We're going to very quickly find out how strong the layers of management at Nvidia are. It's a very flat organization. Jensen's mentioned this and one of the one of the pluses of being a flat organization there are a lot of very smart people who have responsibilities.

One of the downsides of being a flat organization is they tend to be functional specialists. They do something really well in that flat organization. A CEO has got to be able to step back and look at the big picture.

So we'll find out whether the layers of management in Nvidia under the CEO are able to keep this process going

and finally we're going to find out whether the China story as Lex are going to be hearings they're probably going to be legal settings and if Alice Wong turns out to have official ties to the Chinese government and invy's been violating the law by using business fronts to sell chips to the Chinese invites well beyond just replacing CEO And it's a problem that actually will not go away if Jensen Wong comes back as CEO.

In fact, it might be worse if he comes back as CEO.

So, I don't know the answers to these questions. I'm looking for the new stories and over the next few weeks, we will start to get these answers.

My advice is as you look at these answers come through, you make your own judgment. The spreadsheet that I'm going to link to for the session will allow you to trace out what you think the effects will be on revenue growth and margins. and if you feel like it on risk to revalue Nvidia and to see how much value they would lose if Jensen Wong is no no longer there.

So here's the bottom line. If you do think that the board will find a competent replacement CEO match a CEO matches where you are where Invidia is in the life cycle that Jensen will stay involved and work with that CEO and that there's a strong management team and on top of that you throw in the China twist is overblown the value drop will be small so market will recover from the 3.6 trillion back maybe not to the 5.2 two trillion but to a higher number.

But if as the weeks go through the process becomes ugly and toxic and the new CEO is um has frictions with Jens and he and he burns bridges with with employees and the China scandal has legs then the value drop might get worse.

I think this story is a good one to think about when you think about the governance issues I raised with Enthropic. And here's why Jensen Wong has been a great CEO. And as I said, very few people are debated.

But he's also shown that he's human as if that should be a surprise, but they're all human, right? Elon Musk, Dari Amadai, Sam Alman, all of those superstars at the heads of these companies are human. They will make mistakes. That's a given.

Can you imagine if Invidia had two classes of shares and Jensen had a 51% control of the voting rights? This could turn much more toxic. much more quickly if that had happened.

That's one of the things I think great founders do. And I think we're going to get a test of how much Jensen Wong has built an entity that can outlast him in the coming weeks with what Nvidia does.

Watchpoints

whether the China story holds up in hearings and legal proceedings, i.e. Alice Wong has official Chinese government ties and Nvidia sold chips through front companies in violation of the law

What this channel has said about $NVDA

Aswath Damodaran has 2 calls on this stock; only the adjacent ones are shown.

TickerSays