$TSLA · Value Investing with Sven Carlin, Ph.D. · 2026-11-15
我十年来一直对特斯拉持怀疑态度,并认为它在2019年并不是买入标的;我的核心观点是特斯拉不会赚取巨额利润。按年均利润约25亿至宽泛估计的40亿美元、15倍市盈率计算,我对其估值为600亿美元,仅为当前市值的3.89%,并认为特斯拉应值15美元而非390美元;在390美元的水平上,当所有人都在追逐承诺时,明智投资十分困难。
播放时,YouTube 可能接收设备与播放信息并使用 Cookie。 隐私说明 · Google 隐私政策
逐段跳播
周围的环境、Tesla,以及中国。
the surrounding environment, Tesla, and China.
十年来我一直对 Tesla 持怀疑态度,对我来说,Tesla 在 2019 年并不是买入标的,而我是对的。如果这只股票现在涨了 20 倍或 25 倍,我怎么能算对呢?我的论点是 Tesla 不会赚取巨额利润。
I've been skeptical of Tesla for a decade, and for me, Tesla was not a buy in 2019, and I was right. How can I be right if the stock is now 20 or 25 times higher? Well, my thesis was that Tesla would not make huge profits.
看看最新的财务数据,Tesla 的留存收益是 410 亿美元,扣除补贴。Tesla 总共大约在 250 亿美元左右。这是 20 年的净利润总额。
Looking at the latest financial data, Tesla's retained earnings are $41 billion less credits. We are at around $25 billion for Tesla in total. Total net income over 20 years.
我们取他们推出 Tesla 汽车等业务以来 10 年的平均值,每年利润 25 亿美元。就算给他们每年平均利润高达 40 亿美元。40 亿乘以慷慨的 15 倍市盈率,这意味着 600 亿美元的市值。600 亿是当前市值的 3.89%。
Let's take an average of 10 years since they launched Tesla cars and everything, two and a half billion annually in profits. Let's give them up to four billion as average annual profits.
Four billion multiplied by a generous price-to-earnings ratio of 15, that means a market value of 60 billion. 60 billion is 3.89% of the current market value.
在我看来,Tesla 的股票应该值 15 美元,而不是 390 美元。当 Tesla 被估值到 390 美元时,在所有人都在追逐那些承诺的情况下,很难做出明智的投资。
In my opinion, Tesla's stock should be worth $15, not $390. When Tesla is valued at $390, it's difficult to invest wisely while everyone is chasing the promises.
你的投资演示里需要图片和图表。你需要这些。这给市值又增加了 1 万亿美元。永远都是承诺,更多的承诺,网络帽子,这个那个,一切都好极了,一切都在改变我们的生活方式,但大家都忽略了人工智能领域里的某些东西。
You need images and graphs in your investment presentation. You need this. This adds an additional trillion dollars to the market value. It's always promises and more promises, cyber hats, this and that, everything is wonderful , everything is changing the way we live, but everyone is overlooking something in the field of artificial intelligence.
这个频道对 $TSLA 的历次判断
Value Investing with Sven Carlin, Ph.D. 在这只股票上共 3 条判断,这里只列相邻的几条。