Value Investing with Sven Carlin, Ph.D. 对 $TSLA 的判断变化

频道资料 →频道引用的来源:Bill Ackman (20% growth expectation)、Boo、Michael Perry、analysts共 3 条

Value Investing with Sven Carlin, Ph.D. 自 2026-09-16 起在 3 个视频里谈过 $TSLA,最近一次(2026-11-15)为看跌。

2026-11-15看跌
《How difficult it is to be prudent when others aren’t!》
AI 摘要 · 我十年来一直对特斯拉持怀疑态度,并认为它在2019年并不是买入标的;我的核心观点是特斯拉不会赚取巨额利润。按年均利润约25亿至宽泛估计的40亿美元、15倍市盈率计算,我对其估值为600亿美元,仅为当前市值的3.89%,并认为特斯拉应值15美元而非390美元;在390美元的水平上,当所有人都在追逐承诺时,明智投资十分困难。

周围的环境、Tesla,以及中国。

the surrounding environment, Tesla, and China.

十年来我一直对 Tesla 持怀疑态度,对我来说,Tesla 在 2019 年并不是买入标的,而我是对的。如果这只股票现在涨了 20 倍或 25 倍,我怎么能算对呢?我的论点是 Tesla 不会赚取巨额利润。

I've been skeptical of Tesla for a decade, and for me, Tesla was not a buy in 2019, and I was right. How can I be right if the stock is now 20 or 25 times higher? Well, my thesis was that Tesla would not make huge profits.

看看最新的财务数据,Tesla 的留存收益是 410 亿美元,扣除补贴。Tesla 总共大约在 250 亿美元左右。这是 20 年的净利润总额。

Looking at the latest financial data, Tesla's retained earnings are $41 billion less credits. We are at around $25 billion for Tesla in total. Total net income over 20 years.

2026-10-04看跌
《10 Stocks To Buy! Value Investing Quadrant October 2026》
AI 摘要 · 由于缺乏有形利润,TSLA 不可持续,应避免投资。

那么,我们现在从更危险的一侧开始,Tesla 和 SpaceX,从价值投资的角度看,这一切都只是空谈、奇迹和承诺,没有来自汽车或销售的有形利润。所以,这是不可持续的。这很可能有一天会结束。

因此,不应该投资它。这就是为什么我们把它放在这里,零回报。

So, let's start now from the more dangerous side, Tesla and SpaceX, and from a value investment perspective, all of this is just empty talk, miracles and promises, without tangible profits from cars or sales.

So, this is unsustainable. That will likely end someday. Therefore, it should not be invested in. That's why we put it here at zero return.

2026-09-16看跌
I looked at the top 12 Car Stocks! Which is the BEST BUY?
订阅或试用后可见这一步的正文
更早的 1 条正文需要订阅
最近 2 条的正文公开可读。更早的条目保留日期与方向,正文随订阅解锁。
订阅后阅读全部 1 条更早的观点